Three Strikes at Maya's Party
The spinach leaf stuck between my front teeth felt like a flashing neon sign announcing my arrival. I'd been psyching myself up for Maya's party for three days, practicing casual greetings in the mirror, and now I was about to walk in looking like I'd just eaten a salad without using a mirror. Classic Leo move.
I ducked behind the orange tree in Maya's front yard — because apparently her suburban family had an orange tree, like that was normal — and jammed my finger between my teeth. Nothing. I tried my tongue. Still there. I could feel my face burning hotter than the party lights spilling from the windows.
Yo, Leo! You coming in or what?
It was Jordan, leaning against the doorframe with that effortless grace that made me want to simultaneously be her best friend and also disappear into a crack in the pavement. She was wearing this vintage baseball jersey that looked like it had been through actual games, not bought at some thrift store for the aesthetic.
Yeah, just, uh, admiring the citrus situation, I said, because apparently my brain had stopped working.
She laughed. She actually laughed. You're so weird. Come inside, I need someone to help me win the goldfish.
The goldfish. Right. I'd heard about this — Maya's dad had set up this ridiculous carnival game in the backyard, and the prize was an actual living goldfish in a plastic bag. Because fifteen-year-olds definitely needed pets they could win with a 5-cent toss.
I followed Jordan inside, my heart doing that thing where it felt like it was trying to escape my chest. The house was already packed, people I'd known since middle school suddenly transformed into mysterious beings with curated lives and inside jokes I wasn't part of. We wound through the kitchen, past the DJ setup in the living room, and out to the patio where the goldfish game was set up.
Okay, so here's the strategy, Jordan said, pulling me aside. I've been watching people play all night. You gotta throw underhand, like you're pitching a baseball. Spin matters.
I looked at her. You play baseball?
Used to, she said, and something in her voice changed — got softer, sadder. League folded last year when the coach moved. Haven't picked up a bat since.
The confession hung between us, heavier than the humidity. Before I could figure out what to say, she handed me a ping pong ball.
Your turn. Show me what you got, baseball expert.
I threw. I swear I aimed for the bowl, but physics had other opinions. The ball ricocheted off the rim, bounced across the table, and — because the universe had a personal vendetta against me — landed directly in the snack bowl, sinking into a sea of orange cheese dust and triangular fish-shaped crackers.
Jordan stared. I stared. The whole table stared.
And that's when I felt it — the spinach. With a casual sweep of my tongue, I dislodged it. It had migrated. It was no longer visible.
I'd been hiding behind an orange tree for nothing.
Jordan started laughing. Not mean laughing, but actual doubled-over, can't-breathe laughing. You just — your throw — and the goldfish crackers —
I started laughing too. We laughed until my ribs hurt, until the embarrassment dissolved into something else, something warmer. When we finally stopped, Jordan wiped her eyes and handed me another ping pong ball.
Okay, seriously. Try again. Like this — she positioned herself behind me, guiding my arm — more follow-through. Like you're throwing a no-hitter, seventh inning, bases loaded.
The second throw landed perfectly in the bowl. The tiny goldfish — orange, like the tree, like the sunset we watched from the roof later — swam in confused circles in its plastic bag.
We won it together, Jordan said, but she was looking at me, not the fish. Maybe that means something.
Maybe it does, I said, and for the first time all night, I wasn't thinking about spinach, or being cool, or any of the things that usually lived in my head like background noise I couldn't shut off. I was just there, under the string lights, with a girl who understood baseball and laughed at my terrible throws.
The goldfish lived in a bowl on my desk for three years. We called it Winner. Jordan and I called ourselves something else, but that's a story for another time.