The Spinach Smile Catastrophe
Maya had spent forty-five minutes perfecting her hair that morning, curling it into waves that cascaded over her shoulders like she'd just walked off a Pinterest board. Sophomore year was going to be different. No more invisible girl in the back row. This year, she would be seen.
"You look like you're trying too hard," her younger brother Jay had commented from the couch, not looking up from his game.
"Shut up, Jay."
Her cat, Mochi, had chosen that exact moment to jump onto the bathroom counter and knock over her expensive curling cream. Maya had chased the furry traitor through the hallway, slippered feet sliding on hardwood, already running late.
Now she sat in the cafeteria, her heart doing fluttery things because Ethan—the same Ethan she'd been crushing on since seventh grade—was walking toward her table. Actually walking toward her. This was it. The moment her reinvention would officially begin.
"Hey, Maya," he said, and his voice was somehow deeper than she remembered. "We're partners for the English project."
"Oh! Yeah, cool!" She'd practiced this conversation approximately a thousand times in front of her mirror, but her brain was suddenly empty.
They'd talked for five minutes—actual minutes—about The Great Gatsby and how much they both hated it. He'd laughed at her joke about Daisy being a pick-me girl. It was going perfect. Until he'd gestured at his own smile and said, "You've got a little..."
The bathroom mirror had told her everything she needed to know. A piece of spinach from her lunch salad, wedged firmly between her front teeth like a tiny green monument to her humiliation.
Her iphone had buzzed in her pocket—probably Jay asking where she was—but she couldn't bring herself to look. Instead she'd stared at herself, hair still perfect, face still carefully made up, with that one devastating detail ruining everything.
A month later, the school paper published their fall photo spread. There was Ethan looking effortlessly good in his soccer uniform, and there was Maya, caught mid-laugh at a pep rally, spinach incident long forgotten, hair wild because she'd given up on the perfect curls weeks ago.
Ethan had cut out the picture and taped it inside his notebook with a note: *Real smiles > Pinterest ones.*
Somehow, sophomore year really was turning out different than she'd planned. Better, actually.