← All Stories

The Poolside Spy

waterbaseballspy

I never should've agreed to come to Jordan's pool party. But my best friend Chloe swore this was my chance to finally talk to Marcus—the baseball captain who'd been sitting two rows ahead of me in homeroom since freshman year. Now I was lurking behind a potted plant, clutching a red Solo cup like it was a shield, feeling absolutely pathetic.

Marcus stood by the deep end, laughing at something some sophomore in a bikini said. His hair was wet from the **water**, droplets catching the sunlight as he pushed it back. I'd been watching him long enough I probably qualified as a certified **spy** at this point. I knew his post-practice routine (Gatorade blue, always blue), that he tapped his cleat four times before each pitch, and that his ex-girlfriend still watched all his Instagram stories.

Pathetic didn't even cover it anymore.

"You gonna stand there all day or actually talk to him?" Chloe appeared behind me, practically vibrating with secondhand frustration. "You're not in the CIA, Maya. This isn't a reconnaissance mission. It's a party."

"I'm gathering intel," I protested, gesturing vaguely with my cup. "Strategic approach."

"Your strategy is looking at him from across the pool like a creepy mermaid." She grabbed my arm. "Come on. I heard him talking about the **baseball** team's chances at regionals. That's your in."

"My in is pretending I know anything about sports?"

"Fake it 'til you make it, babe. That's literally the whole high school experience."

Before I could overthink it into an anxiety spiral, Marcus turned away from his admirers and our eyes locked. He smiled—that genuine, lopsided thing that made my stomach do embarrassing gymnastics—and started walking toward us.

"Hey," he said, running a hand through his damp hair. "You're Maya, right? From Mr. Henderson's English class?"

I nodded, probably too enthusiastically. "Yeah. Hi. Hello."

Smooth.

"I saw your presentation on The Great Gatsby," he continued, like I wasn't currently malfunctioning. "It was actually really good. Your analysis of the green light symbolism was way better than whatever I came up with."

The mental image I'd constructed of Marcus—shallow jock who only cared about RBI stats and his hair—shattered. He'd listened to my presentation? The one I'd stressed over for three days?

"Thanks," I managed. "I, uh, I like your presentations too. The one on—"

"Don't," he groaned, laughing. "That baseball essay was a disaster. I barely scraped a B minus."

"It wasn't that bad—"

"Maya, I compared the American Dream to getting into the MLB. My teacher looked like she wanted to retire early."

I laughed—really laughed, not the fake one I used when Chloe made me socialize. The tension in my chest loosened, and suddenly I wasn't a spy gathering intel anymore. I was just a girl talking to a boy who, against all odds, might actually be worth crushing on.

"Hey," Marcus said, quieter. "Some of us are grabbing pizza later. You should come."

The world narrowed down to his hopeful expression, the way his eyes crinkled when he smiled, the chlorine smell hanging in the summer air.

"I'd love that," I said, and this time, I didn't feel like I was undercover at all.