← All Stories

The Papaya Incident

baseballpapayabearhairvitamin

My hair looked like a deranged poodle had attacked it. Picture day was tomorrow, and I was currently rocking the kind of hairstyle that screams "I just woke up from a three-day nap." I ran vitamin E oil through it for the third time that morning because my older sister swore it worked miracles. Spoiler: It did not.

"You going to Jordan's party tonight?" asked Tyler, my best friend since fourth grade, leaning against my locker with practiced nonchalance. Tyler had perfect hair—curly in a way that looked effortless, not like he'd been electrocuted.

"I don't know." I adjusted my baseball cap, trying to camouflage the disaster on my head. "Emma might be there."

"Emma? Baseball girl Emma?" He raised an eyebrow. "You still haven't made a move?"

We'd been talking on Instagram for weeks, but whenever I saw her in person, my brain shut down like a computer someone spilled water on. Emma played shortstop, could hit a ball into orbit, and had this smile that made my chest feel weirdly tight.

The party was Jordan's end-of-season baseball celebration. His parents were going all out—exotic fruit platters, actual non-pizza food. Which explains why I found myself at 7 PM, staring at a slice of papaya like it was an alien artifact.

"Try it!" Emma said, appearing beside me. She wore a oversized baseball jersey and cutoff shorts, and my throat went dry.

"I've never had papaya," I admitted. "What if it's gross?"

"You're such a bear sometimes," she laughed, nudging me with her shoulder. "Living in your cave, scared of fruit."

So I tried it. And I kid you not, I nearly spat it out all over her shoes. It tasted like ... I don't even know what. Rotting soap? Perfume gone wrong?

Emma lost it. She was laughing so hard she had to lean against the kitchen counter, her face turning the same color as the offending fruit.

"Your face!" She gasped. "You look so betrayed!"

"I feel betrayed," I said, recovering. "By fruit. Who feels betrayed by fruit?"

"Someone who's never lived a little," she teased, her eyes bright.

Later that night, we sat on Jordan's back porch watching fireflies and talking about everything from baseball to our weird families. I learned her dad made her take chewable vitamins because he didn't trust "regular ones." She learned I'd failed my driving test twice because I kept checking my hair in the rearview mirror.

"Your hair's fine," she said, reaching over to touch it. "It's got character."

"Character is code for 'looks like a poodle attacked it,' isn't it?"

She laughed, this soft genuine sound that made me want to hear it every day. "Maybe. But I like it."

We sat there until her mom came to pick her up, and as she walked away, she turned back. "Hey, you should come to my game Saturday. I'll save you a seat."

I fell asleep that night forgetting about picture day, forgetting about the papaya disaster. Instead, I thought about fireflies and baseball games and a girl who liked my hair even when it looked terrible.

Sometimes the best moments happen when things don't go according to plan. When you try something new and it's awful, but the person next to you laughs, and suddenly everything feels perfect.

Okay, that's cheesy. But whatever. I'm fifteen. I'm allowed to be cheesy sometimes.