← All Stories

The Papaya Incident

iphonepapayabaseballpoolcat

Maya's summer was supposed to be different. This was the year she'd finally talk to Alex—the boy who'd been living in her DMs since seventh grade—without her voice cracking or her palms sweating like they'd just run a marathon.

Now here she was, standing at the edge of Sarah's pool party, clutching her iPhone like a lifeline. Alex was across the yard, playing baseball with his friends, his laugh carrying over the splash of water and Katy Perry blasting from someone's speaker. Maya had spent forty minutes on her hair that morning. She'd even practiced her casual wave in the mirror.

"Yo Maya!" Sarah called, handing her a fruit skewer. "You gotta try this papaya. My mom got it from the specialty market and it's literally life-changing."

Maya hesitated. She'd never had papaya. What if she hated it? What if it made a weird face and Alex saw? But everyone was watching, expecting her to be cool about it. So she took a bite.

And immediately realized she was allergic.

Her lips started tingling. Then swelling. Like, visibly swelling. Within seconds, she looked like she'd been punched in the face.

Maya's cat, Buster, who'd somehow escaped the house and was prowling around the party, chose that exact moment to leap from the pool fence onto her shoulder. Startled, Maya stumbled backward—straight into the pool.

She surfaced sputtering, her puffy lips on full display, while her cat frantically paddled toward the deep end like a determined, furious otter. The baseball game stopped. Alex dropped his bat.

"Oh my god," someone whispered. Then someone else started laughing. Not mean laughing—just the pure chaos kind.

Alex was the one who dove in to fish out Buster, and he was the one who handed Maya a towel while her lips returned to normal size. He was still grinning when he said, "So... that was literally the most metal entrance ever."

Maya could've died. But somehow, with her hair dripping wet and her dignity thoroughly drowned, she laughed too.

"Right?" she said. "At least I'll never have to wonder what would happen if I just went for it."

Alex's phone buzzed in his pocket. He pulled it out, then looked at her. "Wanna get papaya-free snow cones and never speak of this again?"

"Yeah," Maya said. "Yeah, I do."

Some summers, you find yourself exactly when you stop trying to be perfect.