← All Stories

The Papaya Incident

papayabeargoldfishsphinx

Maya's phone buzzed with the party invite—already three rsvps. She stared at her reflection in the bathroom mirror, practicing her chill face. The one that said I'm totally comfortable being the new girl, not at all freaking out about social suicide.

"You're doing that thing again," her little brother Leo announced from the hallway, clutching his plastic goldfish bowl like it contained the crown jewels. "The sphinx face. All mysterious and judgmental."

"Shut up, Leo."

"Mom says you have to take me to Jesse's house since she's working late."

Maya groaned. Jesse's birthday party. The make-or-break social event of sophomore year. And now she'd be chauffeuring the human equivalent of a sticky doorknob.

The party was already in full swing when they arrived. Someone had blasted reggaeton, and the kitchen counter was covered in exotic fruit platters someone's Pinterest-obsessed mom had arranged. Maya reached for what looked like mango, but her teeth sank into something mushy and musky.

"Ew, what IS that?" she sputtered.

"Papaya," said a deep voice behind her.

Maya turned to find Danny Rivera—actual Danny Rivera, varsity basketball captain and walking Greek god statue—watching her with amusement. "It's an acquired taste."

"Clearly one I haven't acquired," Maya managed, wiping her chin with the back of her hand. Smooth.

But Danny laughed. "Nah, it's nasty. I was just messing with you."

They spent the next hour talking about everything and nothing, and Maya forgot about maintaining her sphinx-like mystery. Then Leo appeared, holding out his goldfish bowl.

"Maya, Sir Finbar looks sick!"

"Oh my god, Leo, take him home."

But Danny dropped to his knees, examining the fish. "Dude, that's not sickness. He's just bored. Goldfish need enrichment."

"You know about goldfish?" Maya asked, genuinely surprised.

"Used to have a bunch. My mom made me give them away when we moved." Danny stood up, grinning. "Anyway, I should probably tell you—"

"DANNY!" Someone screamed. "BEAR is here!"

The entire party stampeded toward the door. Maya followed, confused, until she saw the guy in the doorway—some college-aged dude wearing a shirt with a bear on it.

"That's Bear?"

"My older brother," Danny said. "He's home for the weekend."

"You have a brother named Bear?"

"His real name is Javier, but in seventh grade he wore this bear hoodie every day for like six months straight, and it just stuck."

The party shifted into high gear. Bear (Javier?) started doing card tricks. Leo abandoned his fish to watch. And Maya found herself next to Danny on the couch, their shoulders touching, as someone shouted for pizza.

"So," Danny said, "you doing anything tomorrow?"

Maya felt something warm and hopeful bloom in her chest. "Maybe."

"Cool. Cool." He nodded. "I could show you my fish tank. Since you're apparently a goldfish expert by association now."

"I'd like that."

Later that night, Maya's phone lit up with three new notifications. But it was the fourth one—from Danny—that made her smile, sphinx face and papaya disasters and all completely forgotten.