The Papaya Incident
The baseball cap was everything. It sat backwards on Jake's head, declaring to the entire sophomore class that he was chill, unbothered, and totally not obsessing over the fact that Maya hadn't replied to his text in approximately forty-seven minutes.
"Dude, you're literally running in circles," called Tyler from the dugout bench. "You've done eight laps. Is this about Maya?"
Jake slowed to a walk, chest heaving like he'd just run a marathon instead of doing outfield drills. "No. I'm just... getting in shape. For the season."
"Baseball season ended two weeks ago, bro."
Right. Jake adjusted his hat, suddenly remembering why he'd started running in the first place. Because sitting still meant thinking, and thinking meant replaying their last conversation—the one where she'd laughed at his joke but then left early with her friends, and now she was probably at that party he wasn't invited to, and everything was terrible.
His phone buzzed. A notification from Snapchat. Maya had posted a story.
Jake's fingers moved on their own, opening it like a spy decoding enemy intel. There she was, grinning in someone's kitchen, holding up—was that a papaya? Who served papaya at high school parties? What even was this rich-people nonsense?
The caption read: "When your mom tries to be fancy but you just want pizza 😂"
Jake stood frozen in the outfield grass as something shifted inside his chest. She wasn't at some cool-kid exclusive gathering being mysterious. She was at home, probably equally awkward, documenting her mom's failed attempt at gourmet fruit presentation. She was just... Maya.
"You okay, man?" Tyler called. "You look like you've seen a ghost."
Jake's thumbs moved across his screen. He typed: "Papaya? Really? 😏"
Hit send.
Thirty seconds later: "SHUT UP I'm dying it's so gross"
Grinning like an idiot, Jake grabbed his glove and sprinted back toward the dugout. The hat stayed backwards, but suddenly it wasn't a costume anymore. It was just Jake being Jake, and apparently, that was enough.