← All Stories

The Papaya Incident

papayafriendpoolpalmiphone

The pool party at Jade's house was supposed to be chill. Just a few friends, some snacks, maybe some awkward swimming. But that was before The Incident.

I'd been crushing on Marcus since sophomore year, and when he actually showed up at my friend Sierra's gathering, my brain completely short-circuited. I was standing by the pool clutching my iphone like it was a lifeline, desperately trying to look casual and failing spectacularly.

"You want some fruit?" Jade's mom appeared with this gorgeous platter. "Fresh papaya from the farmer's market!"

Papaya. Who even eats papaya? Apparently me, because in my nervous state, I reached for it without thinking. But then Marcus walked over, and suddenly my hands decided they didn't know how to hold things anymore.

The papaya launched into the air in what felt like slow motion. It hit the water with an unimpressive splash and floated there like a confused orange boat.

Everyone stared. Marcus stared. I wanted to dissolve into the pool deck.

"Well," Sierra said, breaking the silence. "That's one way to flavor the pool."

Marcus laughed. Not the mean laugh I expected, but actually amused. "Nice throw," he said, and somehow we ended up sitting on lounge chairs under the palm trees, talking about everything from our terrible taste in music to our mutual hatred of geometry.

The papaya bobbed away in the background, a weird orange witness to my accidental success. By the end of the night, Marcus had my number, and I'd learned that sometimes the most embarrassing moments become the best stories.

Plus, nobody actually ate that papaya, so maybe I did everyone a favor.