← All Stories

The Orange Bullfrog Hat Incident

hatbulldogorange

Maya smoothed her lucky vintage baseball hat—well, technically it was her dad's from 1998, but details mattered less than confidence when you were fifteen and about to humiliate yourself in front of the entire sophomore class. The Fall Fling talent show lineup had been posted that morning, and there it was: MAYA RIVERA, ORIGINAL SONG. Underneath, someone had scrawled "good luck lol" in orange highlighter.

"You're gonna crush it," said Leo, sitting cross-legged on her bedroom floor, tuning his guitar like he'd been doing it forever instead of just since summer band camp. "Also, that hat is sending major main character energy."

Maya snorted. "Oh my god, don't ever say 'main character energy' again. I'm literally shaking."

"It's just stage fright. Happens to everyone. Even my cousinJake, who's literally built different—got chokeslammed by a bull at the county fair last year and still finished his corndog."

"That's not inspirational, that's concerning," she said, though a smile tugged at her mouth. "You think I can do this?"

Leo looked up, and something in his expression made her stomach do that weird fluttery thing it'd been doing since August. "Maya. You wrote a song about your dog's existential crisis. It's literally the best thing I've ever heard, and I say this as someone who owns three Death Cab albums."

"You mean Death Cab for Cutie?"

"Yes, Maya. That is the band's full legal name."

Her dog Buster chose that moment to waddle in, flop dramatically onto the rug, and let out a long, beleaguered sigh that seemed to say, "This too shall pass, though it feels interminable."

"See?" Leo pointed with his guitar pick. "He believes in you."

That night, Maya stood backstage in her orange-highlighted spot on the program, heart hammering against her ribs like a trapped thing. The hat felt ridiculous suddenly, too big, too try-hard. She reached to pull it off—

And then she heard it. A single voice from the middle of the auditorium: "THAT'S MY GIRL!"

She peered through the curtain. There, somehow front and center, was Leo, holding up a crudely drawn sign that said MAYA 4 PRESIDENT in—she squinted—yes, that was definitely ketchup.

Something unclenched in her chest. She adjusted the hat, walked to the mic, and opened her mouth.

The song wasn't perfect. Her voice cracked on the bridge. But when she played the final chord, the silence before the applause felt like the whole world holding its breath, then letting it go.

Afterward, Leo found her behind the gym where she'd escaped to hyperventilate privately.

"You killed it," he said. "Also, I made this.

He handed her a plastic bag from the vending machine. Inside: an orange soda, those weird pretzel nuggets she loved, and a paper napkin with a bull drawn on it in ketchup.

"What's the bull for?"

"Jake," he said simply. "For courage."

Maya laughed so hard she snorted, and when Leo's hand brushed hers reaching for the soda, she didn't pull away.

"Hey," he said, "you free Saturday? There's this—that new record store downtown—"

"Yes," she said, before she could overthink it. "Like, absolutely yes."

Buster woofed from somewhere inside the house, as if to say, Finally.

Maya's phone buzzed. AN UNKNOWN NUMBER: That was incredible. You're gonna be famous someday. - A FRIEND

She smiled. Maybe she didn't know exactly who she was yet. But she knew who she wanted to figure it out with.