← All Stories

The Hat Dare

lightningpyramidhatiphonebear

The pyramid of red solo cups towered three feet high on the kitchen counter, mocking me with its perfect structural integrity. Somewhere between 'never have I ever' and 'truth or dare,' I'd agreed to wear this ridiculous fuzzy top hat — neon green with a fake lightning bolt sticking out the top — until midnight. It was currently 11:47, and Jessica was actually smiling at me from across the room.

I checked my iPhone for the seventeenth time. 11 percent. My stomach did that thing where it feels like I swallowed a entire swarm of bees, which was stupid because I'd been crushing on Jessica since eighth grade and she'd never once looked twice at me until tonight, when I started looking like a displaced rave leprechaun.

"Hey, Hat Boy," she said, sliding up next to me. She smelled like vanilla and expensive shampoo. "Wanna play beer pong?"

"I don't really—" I started, but then she was already pulling me toward the table where the cup pyramid stood.

Outside, lightning cracked across the sky, illuminating the whole house like a strobe light. Someone screamed. The power died.

Darkness. Complete chaos. I felt something heavy and furry brush against my leg and instinctively grabbed it, thinking it was a dog.

"Um, that's my brother's taxidermy bear," Jessica said. "He's weirdly proud of it."

My iPhone flashlight revealed a small stuffed bear in a glass case, mounted on a little wooden platform. "That's... oddly specific?"

She laughed, and in that moment, with everyone else freaking out about the power and me standing there in my stupid lightning bolt hat holding my dying phone like an absolute dweeb, she sat down on the floor next to me.

"You know," she said, "you're actually the only person here who didn't try to act all chill when the lights went out."

"Because I'm not chill," I said. "I'm wearing a green fuzzy hat."

"Exactly." Her phone chimed — her ride was here. She stood up, then paused. "Hey, you should probably text me. So you can tell me when you finally take off that hat."

By the time I got home, my phone was dead. But I remembered her number anyway, because I'd had it memorized since the seventh grade.

I took off the hat at 12:03. Some rules are worth breaking.