← All Stories

The Green Between My Teeth

orangefriendspinachbaseball

My mom packed spinach salad for the first day of freshman year. Spinach. Like she wanted me to be that kid — the one whose lunch smells like a compost bin and whose social status dies before second period.

I'd spent all summer carefully curating my aesthetic: vintage baseball tees (actually my dad's old ones, but I told everyone I thrifted them), carefully messy hair, and the ability to look mildly bored by everything. This was my rebrand. No more middle-school me. High school Marcus was gonna be effortlessly cool.

Then there was the orange incident in homeroom. My Crush — let's call her Sam, because that's her name and I'm not creative — sat two rows over. I went for a casual hair flip. My elbow connected with my open Tropicana. The bright orange splash decorated my white tee like a violent sunrise.

Half the class stared. Sam definitely did.

"Nice look," whispered the guy behind me. Jake. I'd known him since third grade, back when being the weird kid who ate spinach sandwiches was socially acceptable.

I grabbed my backpack and bolted to the bathroom, locking myself in a stall to examine the damage. The orange stain looked like a target. My phone buzzed.

Jake: u good??

Me: never speaking again

Jake: lol come back

I didn't come back. I spent lunch in the library, picking at my spinach salad and feeling like the biggest fraud to ever walk the earth. All that work crafting a persona, destroyed by juice and my own inability to function like a normal human being.

The bathroom door creaked open.

"Marcus?" Jake's voice.

"Go away."

"Dude, you've been in here for twenty minutes. Also, you have spinach in your teeth."

I froze. "How long?"

"Since lunch started. I was trying to be a friend and tell you privately, but you decided to hide in a stall instead."

I started laughing. I couldn't help it. Everything about today was so ridiculous. Jake sat on the floor outside my stall while I picked spinach from my braces, and we talked for the whole period. Not about cool stuff. About our parents' weird lunches, about how we were both terrified of high school, about how his baseball tryouts went that morning (he made varsity but his hands wouldn't stop shaking).

"You know," he said, as the bell rang, "nobody cares about the orange shirt. Everyone's too busy worrying about their own stuff."

I looked in the mirror. The stain was still there, bright and unignorable. But somehow it didn't matter anymore.

"Hey Jake?"

"Yeah?"

"Thanks. For, like, everything."

He shrugged. "Anytime. Also, maybe bring a sandwich tomorrow? Just a thought."

Walking to class, I caught Sam's eye in the hallway. She smiled.

"Love the shirt," she said. "It's bold."

Maybe fake effortless cool was overrated anyway. The real thing — spinach teeth and all — felt surprisingly okay.