← All Stories

The Goldfish Incident

orangeiphonedoggoldfishcat

Maya's iPhone buzzed for the third time in two minutes. She ignored it, just like she'd been ignoring everything since transferring to Northwood High three weeks ago. Being the new girl sucked, especially when your mom dragged you across the country in the middle of sophomore year because "the vibes in Portland are just better for your artistic soul, Maya."

"You coming?" Riley called from downstairs. Maya's older sister was already flourishing at her new college classes, naturally outgoing and effortlessly cool. Maya was still trying to figure out which lunch table wouldn't social-suicide her.

"Be there in a sec!"

Maya scooped up Clementine, her cat, who'd been kneading her duvet like it contained the secrets to the universe. "Sorry, Clem. Riley's boyfriend is picking us up for the pet store run. Remember? We're getting funeral fish for Mr. Henderson's memorial service."

Mr. Henderson had been their apartment building's grumpy superintendent until last week. The man had hated everything—especially joy—but had somehow kept a goldfish pond in the courtyard that he'd insisted brought him "a moment's peace in this hellscape." Now his estranged daughter was organizing a small memorial, and Riley—being Riley—had volunteered to restock the pond in his honor.

The car ride was awkward. Jason, Riley's boyfriend, drove an orange vintage Mustang that smelled like pine air freshener and repressed memories. He kept trying to make conversation with Maya, asking about her interests, her classes at Northwood, whether she'd found her people yet.

"I'm good," Maya kept saying. "Still adjusting."

The pet store was chaos. Someone's dog had gotten loose, a golden retriever puppy that was now weaving between customers while its owner frantically apologized to everyone within earshot. Maya watched it bound toward the fish aisle, tail wagging like it had just discovered its life's purpose.

Then she saw him. Leo, from her AP Literature class. The guy who sat three rows back and always looked like he was solving the world's problems in his head. He was crouched by the goldfish tanks, carefully selecting fish while somehow making the whole thing look like an act of quiet rebellion.

The dog chose that moment to launch itself at Leo, who laughed—actually laughed—and caught it mid-leap, nearly knocking over a display of cat treats in the process.

"Buster! NO!" The dog's owner rushed over, face crimson. "I am so sorry, this is so embarrassing—"

"It's cool." Leo grinned, setting the dog down gently. "Honestly? Best thing that's happened all week." His eyes met Maya's, and something shifted—recognition, then something else. "Hey, you're in my lit class, right?"

Maya nodded, suddenly hyperaware that her phone was buzzing again (her mom, probably, checking in) and that she was standing in the middle of PetSmart with a bag of fish supplies and absolutely no game.

"I'm Leo."

"Maya."

"You need help picking out fish? Because I have strong opinions about goldfish welfare, and I'm not afraid to use them."

The dog's owner apologized again, and Leo made some joke about how Buster clearly just wanted to help pick fish, and Maya found herself smiling—really smiling—for what felt like the first time in weeks. They picked out three goldfish together, making up personalities for each one. The orange one was definitely named Tony, because of course it was.

Later, at the memorial service, as they released the fish into Mr. Henderson's pond, Maya's phone buzzed one last time.

From an unknown number: Hey, it's Leo. Tony seems like he's thriving. Also, there's a coffee shop on 4th that has the best cold brew. Want to check it out this weekend?

Maya typed back before she could overthink it.

Absolutely.

Behind her, Riley whispered, "Spill. NOW."

Maya just smiled, watching the fish glide through dark water, somehow lighter than she'd felt in months. Maybe Portland wouldn't be so bad after all.