← All Stories

The Goldfish Incident

goldfishorangevitamincathat

Marcus stood in front of his mirror for twenty minutes, adjusting the orange snapback for the thirty-seventh time. It was his older brother's hat, stolen from the closet specifically because Lily had mentioned she liked guys who wore hats. That was, like, three months ago, but details mattered.

"You look ridiculous," his sister announced from the doorway, where she was filming his pre-game ritual for TikTok. "A cat walked on your head and died there."

"It's called style, Kennedy. Look it up."

The house party was already in full swing when Marcus arrived. Someone's parents were conveniently out of town, the universal signal for chaos. He spotted Lily immediately—she was by the snack table, laughing at something Tyler was saying. Tyler, who played varsity everything and had never worn an ugly hat in his life.

Marcus made his way over, grabbing a handful of goldfish crackers because his hands were shaking and he needed an excuse to be standing there. This was it. The moment he'd been lowkey stressing about since freshman year.

"Hey, Marcus!" Lily smiled, and it was somehow even better than he remembered. "Love the hat. Very... bold."

"Yeah, it's a whole vibe," he said, and immediately wanted to dissolve into the floorboards. Since when did he say "vibe" unironically?

Tyler snorted into his red cup. "Bold choice. Really pops against your complexion."

Marcus felt his face heating up. He should've stayed home. He should've never stolen his brother's hat. He should've—

"Anyway," Lily said, giving Tyler a look that shut him up. "Marcus, I actually wanted to ask you something. You're in AP Bio, right?"

"Uh, yeah. Why?"

"I need help with the vitamin unit." She stepped closer, suddenly invading his personal space in the best way possible. "The whole absorption process is literally not making sense. Could you maybe tutor me?"

Marcus blinked. "Wait, really?"

"Really. Unless you're too busy being aesthetic in that hat."

Kennedy was going to lose it when she heard about this. Marcus adjusted his snapback, finally feeling like he might actually pull it off. "I'm never too busy for bio, Lily."

Later that night, he'd realize Tyler had been joking about the hat, but Lily wasn't. And sometimes, weirdly enough, that was enough.