← All Stories

The Goldfish in the Deep End

swimmingwatercablegoldfishhat

Pool parties at Jasmine's house were legendary. The kind everyone talked about at school on Monday. But me? I felt like a literal goldfish in a bowl—glass walls everywhere, everyone watching, absolutely zero clue how to look natural.

I stood by the snack table, clutching my red baseball hat like it was some kind of emotional support animal. My hair was doing that thing where it looked like I'd just rolled out of bed, which, plot twist, I basically had.

"Yo Marcus, you gonna stand there all day or actually get in?" That was Tyler, already shirtless, already having the time of his life, already making everything look effortless.

"Yeah, yeah, gimme a sec."

I stared at the swimming pool like it was a portal to another dimension. The water sparkled with that ridiculous perfect-blue filter that only exists in real life at rich people's houses. Everyone was splashing, laughing, flirting. Maya was there. Maya, who I'd been lowkey obsessed with since September, was currently floating on an inflatable pizza slice looking like an actual Disney princess.

My phone buzzed. Mom: "Don't forget we're getting internet installed tomorrow! The cable guy's coming between 8-12 🎉"

Thanks, Mom. Real helpful timing.

I took a breath. Just jump in. Literally and metaphorically. That's what the self-help YouTube videos always said. Lean into the discomfort. Embrace the awkward.

I dropped my hat on a lawn chair. Heart pounding like I was about to give a presentation without preparing anything. I walked to the edge of the pool.

"Marcus! Finally!" Maya called out. "We're playing chicken. You and Tyler versus me and Jasmine."

Chicken. Of course. The most contact-sport game that wasn't actually a sport. Perfect.

I dove in.

The water swallowed me up, cool and shocking and suddenly everything was simple. Underneath the surface, nobody was watching. Nobody was expecting anything. Just me and the water and the weird peaceful feeling of holding my breath.

Then I broke the surface, gasping, and Maya was right there smiling like she'd been waiting for me to join them all along.

"Took you long enough," she said, splashing water in my face.

And somehow, impossibly, I was laughing. "Yeah, well. I'm dramatic like that."

Tyler climbed onto my shoulders, and Maya climbed onto Jasmine's, and we were all screaming and shoving each other and nobody cared that I'd spent the first twenty minutes standing by the chips like a socially anxious ghost.

Later, when we were all sprawled on towels watching the sun dip below the fence, Maya handed me my hat. "You forgot this."

"Thanks." I put it on, feeling somehow different. "You know, I still don't know how to swim properly."

She laughed. "Literally none of us do. We're all just pretending. That's the whole thing about being seventeen. Nobody knows what they're doing. We're all just swimming in circles until we figure it out."

I looked around at everyone—Tyler, Jasmine, all the people I'd spent years overthinking and assuming had it all together. They didn't. They were just better at faking it.

"Swimming in circles," I repeated. "Like goldfish."

"Exactly," she said, bumping my shoulder with hers. "But at least we're doing it together."