The Girl Who Wasn't a Riddle
Everyone called her Sphinx — maya, with her perfect eyeliner and unreadable expression, sitting at the back of honors English like she'd already figured out all the answers and found them wanting. I'd been lowkey spying on her since September, watching from my corner seat in third period like some total creep, building this whole mythology in my head about how she must be deep and profound and absolutely unapproachable.
So when she showed up at Jordan's pool party last Friday, I basically forgot how to human. I spent twenty minutes pretending to examine the ingredient list on a bag of chips while she sat by the water in cutoffs and an oversized band tee, looking like she'd rather be literally anywhere else.
"You gonna stand there all night or you gonna jump in?"
I nearly jumped out of my skin. She was right behind me, holding two sodas. The Sphinx. Up close, I could see a tiny freckle on her chin and the way her hands were actually kind of shaking.
"I — uh."
Smooth. Truly award-winning social skills.
She cracked this tiny smile, like she was laughing at herself more than me. "I'm Maya, by the way. Not that anyone actually uses my name anymore."
"Leo," I managed, because apparently I'd forgotten how words worked.
We ended up sitting on the pool edge, feet dangling in the water, and somehow we started talking about everything — how she wasn't mysterious, just socially anxious, how I wasn't cool, just pretending to be. Turns out the Sphinx was just a girl who overthought everything and didn't know how to start conversations, same as me. The water rippled around our legs, reflecting the string lights overhead, and for the first time all year, I didn't feel like I was spying on someone else's life. I felt like I was actually living my own.
"Hey," she said, as the party started winding down. "You wanna hang out tomorrow? Maybe actually talk instead of staring at each other across classrooms?"
I smiled. "Yeah. Yeah, I'd like that."
Some riddles, it turns out, aren't meant to be solved alone.