← All Stories

The Friday I Came Undone

dogcatbear

The bear costume smelled like three years of teenage sweat and bad decisions. I tugged at the polyester head, already regretting letting Maya dare me into wearing the North High mascot outfit for homecoming. "Just own it, Brody," she'd said. Easy for her to say—she wasn't the one sweating through fifth period in a fuzzy brown prison.

Then my phone buzzed. CheetoGirl99: "meet me by the concession stand at halftime??"

My stomach dropped. CheetoGirl99—aka Chloe, the prettiest girl in AP Bio, who'd been DMing me all week about our shared obsession with gummy worms and obscure indie bands. I'd never mentioned I wasn't actually cool. I'd let her believe I was the mysterious skater guy from three towns over, not Brody Miller, who once cried because his dog ate his science fair project.

"You're gonna catfish yourself into loneliness," my sister had warned yesterday, catching me mid-DM. Then she'd done that thing where she dogged my every move for the rest of the night, asking if "the mysterious skater" needed help tying his shoes. Kayla was a sophomore now, which apparently meant she'd ascended to professional annoying sibling status.

Halftime couldn't come fast enough. The marching band was doing something that sounded suspiciously like a pump-up remix meant for basketball games, not football. I waddled toward the concession stand, the bear head bobbing like a doomed bobblehead.

Chloe was there, scrolling through her phone. I froze. This was it. The moment I'd have to explain that Brody Miller, bear-costume-wearing sophomore, had been pretending to be someone else entirely.

Then she looked up and spotted me. Her eyes went wide, then she started laughing—not mean laughing, but actual giggles. "Brody?"

I pulled off the bear head. My hair was sticking up in ten directions. "I can explain."

"You're CheetoGirl99?" I blurted.

She laughed harder. "Dude. I saw your skateboard in your Instagram stories from last year. I knew it was you."

"Wait, what?"

"I was catfishing YOU to see if you'd own up to it," she said, grinning. "Also, I think your dog is cute. No offense about the science fair thing."

I stood there, sweaty and holding a giant bear head, realizing this night couldn't have gone more wrong—or more right. Kayla appeared behind Chloe, smirking like she'd planned the whole thing.

"Told you," she said. "Bear with it, bro."