← All Stories

The Fox Who Called Bull

papayafoxbull

Maya had spent forty-five minutes perfecting the eyeliner wing that refused to cooperate, which already felt like a personal attack from the universe. Tonight was Lucas's party—the first actual rager of sophomore year—and if she showed up looking anything less than legendary, she might as well transfer schools.

"You ready?" her older brother called from downstairs. "Or are you still doing that thing where you stress-applies mascara until you look like a sad panda?"

"Shut up, Jake!" Maya grabbed her phone and practically vaulted down the stairs. Outside, a beat-up Honda Civic idled at the curb—Harper's ride. Harper, whose wardrobe consisted entirely of thrifted flannel and inexplicable confidence.

"Hop in, loser," Harper said, blasting some indie band Maya had never heard of but nodded along to anyway because that's what you did when someone was radiating that much cool energy.

The party was already in full swing when they arrived. Lucas's parents were supposedly "out of town" (Maya had questions about how often this happened), and the living room had transformed into a sea of solo cups and Snapchat stories being filmed in real time. Maya immediately spotted him—Lucas, leaning against the kitchen doorway with that effortless thing he did, like being attractive was just his side hustle.

Then she saw Riley.

Riley, who wore crop tops before it was warm enough and had once allegedly made out with a college guy at a concert. Riley, currently holding court near the island where someone's mom had apparently arranged fruit that no one was actually eating. And there it was—a sliced papaya, glistening under recessed lighting like it belonged there.

"Oh my god, have you guys tried this?" Riley was saying, her voice carrying over the bass thumping from the speakers. "My mom gets them imported from her farm in Costa Rica. They're literally a whole different vibe than regular papaya."

Maya wanted to roll her eyes so hard they might get stuck. Imported papaya. What was next, artisanal air?

"That's such bull," someone said.

Maya turned. It was that quiet guy from her English class—what was his name? Finn? Fox? Something with an F. He was wearing a jacket that had definitely seen better decades and holding a cup like it contained secrets instead of whatever mysterious punch was being served.

"Excuse me?" Riley's voice sharpened. All eyes landed on Fox. That was definitely his name. Fox, who sat behind her in third period and never spoke unless directly asked a question, and even then, it was like pulling teeth.

"Your mom's farm in Costa Rica," Fox said, completely unintimidated. "You told everyone in September she was a travel nurse. Which is it?"

The room went quiet. Not like, someone-turned-down-the-music quiet. Like, the air had been sucked out of the room quiet.

Maya watched Riley's face cycle through at least three emotions before landing on something that looked dangerously close to tears. And suddenly, Maya remembered—that time in the locker room when Riley had helped her pick up her scattered books after someone had knocked them over. How Riley had complimented her earrings during midterms. How maybe, just maybe, Riley was trying too hard because she was trying too hard, and wasn't that just all of them, always?

"Okay, but have you actually HAD papaya from Costa Rica?" Maya heard herself say. All eyes shifted to her, and she felt her face burn. "Because, like, tropical produce hits different. Just saying."

Fox raised an eyebrow at her. A tiny smirk played at the corner of his mouth.

"Touché," he said.

Riley let out this breath that sounded like she'd been holding it for a solid minute. "Exactly! Thank you! Some people get it."

"I'm Fox, by the way," Quiet Guy said to Maya, as the party slowly remembered how to exist. "And you're absolutely right about the papaya. Costa Rican soil is basically magic."

He winked. Maya felt something weird happen in her chest, like her heart had forgotten how to heart properly.

"Maya," she managed. "And I was literally just guessing."

"Best kind of guess," Fox said. "Want to try this allegedly imported papaya before someone decides it's bull and we all miss out?"

She laughed, and Lucas finally looked over from the kitchen doorway. And maybe—just maybe—tonight wouldn't be a disaster after all.