← All Stories

The Dog That Broke My Cover

dogfriendspybaseball

I was living a double life, and honestly? The benefits were mid at best.

On Instagram, I was @baseworkqueen98, posting grainy aesthetic photos of the high school baseball field at sunset. I had 400 followers and zero friends in real life who knew about my secret account. I was basically a spy in my own school, lurking on the popular kids' stories, analyzing their captions like they were ancient texts.

The mission? Figure out why my former best friend Sarah stopped talking to me three months ago.

"You're being unhinged," my friend Leo said, scrolling through TikTok on my bed while I refresh-stalked Sarah's profile for the twentieth time that hour. "Just text her."

"You don't get it," I muttered. "She posted a pic at the baseball diamond today. That's OUR spot. She knows I'll see it. It's a message."

Leo rolled his eyes so hard I thought they might get stuck. "Or maybe she just likes baseball? Not everything is about you, Maya."

I ignored him because OBVIOUSLY it was about me. Everything always was.

The next afternoon, I took my dog Buster to the actual baseball field. I didn't know what I was looking for — clues? closure? a sign from the universe? — but I ended up behind the backstop, lurking in the shadows like a total weirdo.

Then I saw them. Sarah and some girl from the debate team, sitting on the bleachers. They were... holding hands?

My stomach dropped. Was she dating someone? Was that why she ghosted me? Because she thought I'd be homophobic? She knew I was bi. She'd been at my house when I came out to my parents sophomore year.

I was about to creep away and process my trauma in peace when Buster spotted them.

My otherwise-chill golden retriever decided THIS was his moment to shine. He bolted toward the bleachers, leash trailing behind him like a comet tail, barking his head off like they were intruders in HIS territory.

"Buster, NO!" I hissed, sprinting after him.

Too late. He reached them, tail wagging, tongue out, living his best life. Sarah and her friend jumped apart, faces flushing.

Then Sarah saw me.

The silence that followed was absolutely excruciating.

"Maya?" she said, and her voice cracked. "What are you — were you watching us?"

I wanted to die. I wanted to dissolve into the grass and become one with the earth.

"I was just... walking my dog," I said lamely. "And then he... ran. And I followed. Because that's what you do. When your dog runs."

The girl next to Sarah looked between us, eyes wide. "Is this the Maya you told me about? The one who —"

"Don't," Sarah said quickly, but it was too late.

"The one you thought would judge you for being gay?" the girl finished anyway, because some people have no chill.

I stared at her. "Wait. You ghosted me because you thought I'd have a problem with you being gay?"

Sarah's face burned. "You never really had friends who were queer before. You were all dramatic about your label and I didn't think you'd get it. I thought you'd make it weird."

"Sarah," I said. "I'm LITERALLY bi. We talked about this. You helped me pick out my outfit for pride."

"I know!" She put her face in her hands. "I wasn't thinking straight. I was scared. And then too much time passed and I didn't know how to fix it."

Buster sat between us, looking proud of himself like he'd just orchestrated world peace.

"Well," I said, "congratulations. You succeeded in making it weird."

Sarah laughed, and it was the same laugh she'd had since we were six, and suddenly I was crying and she was crying and we were hugging in the middle of the baseball field while Buster licked both our faces.

"I'm sorry," she whispered into my hair. "I missed you so much."

"Yeah, well," I sniffled. "Next time you think I'm going to be a homophobe, maybe just ASK me instead of assuming?"

"Deal."

Her friend was still sitting on the bleachers, looking uncomfortable. "Hi," she said. "I'm Chloe. I'm the girlfriend."

"Hi Chloe," I said. "I'm the dramatic bi friend who apparently needs to work on communication."

Leo was never going to let me hear the end of this.

But honestly? Worth it.