Spinach Teeth & The Carnival Goldfish
The carnival goldfish—dubbed Neptune by the carny who clearly didn't care—swam in pathetic circles inside a plastic bag that Maya had somehow agreed to hold. This wasn't even her goldfish. She was just the placeholder because Jake couldn't bring a fish into the party without his mom absolutely losing it.
"You're literally holding a hostage situation," Jake said, gesturing at the bag with his red Solo cup. Liquid sloshed dangerously close to Neptune.
Maya tightened her grip on the bag. "First of all, Neptune is free in like thirty minutes when your mom gets home. Second, stop waving that around. You're gonna die of alcohol poisoning before you're legally allowed to buy it."
The kitchen was packed—seniors mostly, allposturing and performative laughter. Maya had spinach in her teeth. She could FEEL it. She'd caught her reflection in the microwave earlier and there it was: a perfect green wedge lodged between her front teeth, broadcasting her insecurity to everyone who made eye contact.
And Bear—actual nickname for the six-foot-three linebacker whose real name was Tyler—was currently trapping her in the corner.
"So," Bear said, leaning against the refrigerator. "You and Jake, like..."
"No," Maya said. "He needed a fish sitter. I'm literally doing community service at this point."
Bear laughed. His eyes kept darting to her mouth. To the spinach. She knew he saw it. He definitely saw it. The entire football team probably knew about Spinach Girl by now.
"You want help with that?" Bear asked, gesturing vaguely toward his own teeth.
Maya's face burned. "There's nothing to help with."
"Your tooth," Bear said, cringing in that way where his whole face scrunched up. "You've got..."
"Spinach," she whispered. "I know. I've known for forty-five minutes. I just haven't found a socially acceptable way to stick my entire hand in my mouth and fix it."
Bear considered this. Then: "I have a mirror in my car."
"You brought your car to a house party?"
"I've got practice at 6 AM," he said with a shrug. "My life is a curated nightmare."
Maya snorted. Then she actually laughed.
Ten minutes later, she fixed the spinach situation in Bear's passenger seat mirror while Neptune swam lazy circles in the dashboard light. Bear sat in the driver's seat, not making fun of her, not making it weird—just scrolling through Spotify and asking what kind of music she liked.
"Anything that isn't mumble rap," she said, wiping the last green fleck from her tooth with a paper towel.
"Cool," Bear said. "I can work with that."
When they went back inside, Jake was nowhere to be found and Neptune's bag was floating in the punch bowl.
Maya looked at Bear. Bear looked at Maya.
"Well," she said. "That's one way to do it."
Bear laughed—really laughed, head thrown back, no pretense. "High school, man. What are you gonna do?"
She walked home alone that night, spinach-free and fish-less, her phone buzzing with a new contact: BEAR 🐻 (sorry about the fish).