← All Stories

Spinach-Stained Smile

vitaminspinachwater

I was determined to become a whole new person for freshman year. Gone was the quiet girl who sat in the back with her frizzy hair and worn-out sneakers. This year, I'd be confident, radiant, effortlessly cool.

The plan started with a multivitamin regimen from GNC. The clerk said these particular ones would give me 'glow energy,' which sounded exactly like what I needed. I took two every morning with a full glass of water, standing in front of the bathroom mirror like I was summoning a transformation.

Then came the spinach.

My sister Maya rolled her eyes when she saw me making green smoothies. 'You're trying too hard, little cuz. Just be yourself.' But what did she know? She was a senior with perfect skin and a boyfriend who played varsity basketball. She'd never had to reinvent anything.

Wednesday of the first week, I marched into the cafeteria with my Tupperware of spinach salad, feeling powerful. This was it. This was the moment everyone would notice New Lena. I sat at a table near— but not too near— the popular kids. Jordan Rivera, the sophomore everyone had a crush on, was laughing at something his friend said. His smile literally lit up the entire room.

I took a confident bite of my spinach salad.

And felt a piece of green leaf lodge itself squarely between my front teeth.

I froze. Do I spit it out? Do I swallow it whole? Do I casually try to work it loose with my tongue? My face started burning like I'd swallowed the sun instead of spinach. I glanced up and caught Jordan's eye— and he was definitely, absolutely looking at the giant green flag waving from my smile.

'Hey,' he said, sliding into the seat across from me. 'You got a little—' He gestured to his own teeth, grinning.

I wanted to die. Actually die. Right there in the cafeteria with my spinach salad and my vitamin water and my entire existence.

But then he laughed. Not mean laughing. Real laughing.

'I did the exact same thing last year with kale,' Jordan said. 'Thought I'd become a health guru over the summer. My friends called me Kale Boy for three months.'

I started laughing too. The kind of laugh that makes your stomach hurt and your eyes water. And just like that, the new person I'd been trying to become didn't matter anymore.

'Want some?' I pushed my Tupperware toward him. 'It's actually pretty good.'

Jordan took a fork. 'Only if you tell me where you got those glow vitamins.'

We sat there talking until the bell rang, and I realized something Maya had been trying to tell me all along: nobody falls in love with the perfect version of you. They fall for the real you— spinach stains and all.