← All Stories

Spinach Smile

catwaterspinach

Maya's cat, Biscuit, headbutted her ankle at exactly 7:03 PM—five minutes before Jordan was supposed to pick her up for what she'd been calling 'The Thing' in her head because saying 'first date' made it too real, too terrifying.

"Not helping, Biscuit," she muttered, smoothing her dress for the forty-third time. Her phone buzzed. *Running 5 min late. Be there soon. 💙* The blue heart made her stomach do that flip-flop thing that was equal parts amazing and nauseating.

She'd spent two hours on her makeup, watching tutorials, rewinding, restarting. The eyeliner was still slightly uneven but she decided to own it. Casual effortlessness. That was the vibe.

Her mom called from the kitchen. "Maya, honey, did you eat? I made that spinach and artichoke dip you—"

"Not hungry, Mom! We're getting food!"

The doorbell rang. Biscuit bolted.

Maya opened the door and there he was. Jordan. In that leather jacket he always wore, hair falling across his forehead like he didn't care, but you knew he totally did. He smelled like cologne and something else—rain? No, just fresh air. Like he'd been outside waiting.

"Hey," he said. "You look... wow."

"Yeah?" She felt her face burning. "You too."

They walked to his car, and she was hyper-aware of everything—her arms swinging (too much?), her walk (did she always walk like this?), the silence between them (why wasn't he talking?). But then he opened her door and she thought, okay, this is actually happening.

The party was at Tyler's house—people from school, some she knew, some she'd only seen in the hallways. Someone's playlist was too loud. Someone was definitely vaping in the bathroom. The air smelled like cheap body spray and anxiety.

Jordan got them drinks. They stood by the sliding glass door that led to the backyard, where people were gathered around something.

"What's happening out there?" she asked.

"Oh, Tyler's cat got stuck in a tree. Or maybe it's not stuck? Everyone's taking videos." He rolled his eyes. "People are weird."

She laughed, and that's when it happened. Jordan looked at her, really looked at her, and said, "You've got really great teeth."

Her heart soared. Then CRASHED.

Because in that moment, Maya remembered: she'd eaten that spinach dip while rushing through makeup application. She'd checked her teeth. Had she though? REALLY checked?

She grabbed her phone, flipped to selfie mode, and—

Spinach. Nestled in her front left tooth like a tiny green banner announcing her doom. How long? Since she opened the door? Since the car ride? Since she'd been standing here smiling at Jordan like everything was fine?

"I'll be right back," she choked out, practically running to the bathroom.

She locked the door and stared at herself in the mirror, spinach now gone thanks to aggressive scrubbing with her fingernail. Her eyes were watering. She could hear people outside laughing, living their normal spinach-free lives.

Her phone buzzed again. *You okay?*

She didn't know what was worse—the spinach or the fact that he'd definitely noticed and hadn't said anything until now. Or had he? Had it been cute? No. Nothing about spinach in teeth is cute. It's just tragic.

She splashed cold water on her face. Okay. This was fine. This was just... character development. One day she'd laugh about this. Maybe in ten years. Possibly twenty.

When she finally came out, Jordan was still by the door, exactly where she'd left him. He looked up, and his expression wasn't pity or amusement or anything she'd prepared herself for.

"I was going to tell you," he said. "But then I realized I didn't want to be that guy who makes a big deal out of nothing. Also, full disclosure—I had cereal before I picked you up and there's probably milk mustache situation happening."

Maya let out a breath she didn't know she'd been holding. Then she was laughing, really laughing, and Jordan was too, and it wasn't perfect but it was real.

"Wanna get out of here?" he asked. "There's this spot by the river. No spinach allowed."

"Yes," she said. "God, yes."

When they got home that night, Biscuit was waiting by the door like a tiny, judgmental sentinel. Maya scooped him up, burying her face in his fur. He purred loudly, like he'd been the emotional support all along.

Her mom peeked out from the kitchen. "How was it?"

Maya smiled, and this time she didn't check her teeth. "Perfect. Actually perfect."