← All Stories

Riddles in the Deep End

poolsphinxbaseballfoxgoldfish

Maya stared at her reflection in the cafeteria's jello cup—distorted, wobbly, barely recognizable. Freshman year at Northwood High was basically a twelve-month crash course in feeling like an imposter in your own life.

"Earth to Maya," Jordan said, snapping his fingers. "Baseball tryouts start next week. You coming or what?"

"I don't know." Maya poked at the jello. "I'm not exactly varsity material."

"Dude, you've got a cannon for an arm. Don't be such a—"

"A what?"

"A chicken. Also, your lunch is staring at you."

The goldfish in the cup-shaped jello did seem kind of judgmental. Maya swiped the cup and headed toward her sanctuary: the abandoned indoor pool behind the gym. Nobody went there anymore unless they were ditching third period, which Maya absolutely was.

The pool sat drained and empty, except for the new construction next to it—a half-assembled papier-mâché sphinx for the upcoming Egyptian-themed homecoming dance. Its paint was peeling already. Maya flopped onto the pool's concrete bottom, staring up at the sphinx's toothy grin.

"Nice hideout," a voice said from above.

Maya jumped. Riley, the junior who wore thrifted jackets and always had paint under her fingernails, peered down from the pool's edge. Her auburn hair caught the light—fox-colored, Maya thought, which was weirdly specific.

"Nice sphinx," Maya shot back.

Riley laughed and dropped down beside her. "It's a hot mess. Art club had three weeks and zero budget. Kind of like this school, honestly."

"Preach."

"So what's your deal? Why the pool?"

Maya hesitated, then spilled everything—the pressure to fit in, Jordan's baseball invitations, the constant background radiation of anxiety that she'd chosen wrong. "I feel like I'm waiting for the actual me to show up. Like maybe she got lost somewhere between middle school and now."

Riley nodded slowly. "The sphinx asks a riddle before you pass. Want to know what ours is?"

"Hit me."

"Who are you when nobody's watching?"

The question hung in the empty pool like smoke.

"I don't know," Maya said quietly. "Maybe that's the problem."

"Or maybe that's the point." Riley stood up and extended a hand. "We're all making it up as we go. Nobody actually knows what they're doing. We're all just faking it till we make it not fake anymore."

Maya took her hand. "That's both reassuring and terrifying."

"Welcome to high school." Riley pulled her up. "Hey, art club needs help with the sphinx tomorrow. You in? No experience necessary, just a willingness to get paint everywhere."

Maya looked at the sphinx's enigmatic face, then at Jordan's baseball field visible through the gym windows, then back at Riley.

"Yeah," she said, surprising herself. "Yeah, I'm in."

Later, Jordan found Maya by the sphinx, paint streaking her cheek like war paint.

"So, baseball?" he asked.

"Maybe next season," Maya said. "I've got some riddles to solve first."