← All Stories

Riddles at the Deep End

papayasphinxpool

Maya stood at the edge of the pool, clutching her phone like a lifeline. The graduation party was in full swing—music thumping, seniors splashing, someone doing cannonballs off the diving board. She'd barely spoken to half these people in four years, and now they expected her to celebrate together like they hadn't spent the past month avoiding each other in the halls.

"You gonna jump in or what?"

Maya turned to find Chloe perched on the pool ladder, dripping wet. Chloe-the-sphinx, as Maya had secretly called her since sophomore year. Pretty, untouchable, always with that slight smile that made you wonder if she knew something you didn't. Chloe had been captain of the debate team, president of student council, and somehow still managed to sit alone at lunch reading philosophy books.

"I'm good," Maya said, too quickly.

Chloe tilted her head. "That's not an answer."

Before Maya could respond, a red solo cup was shoved into her hand. It was Kevin from AP Calc, grinning like he'd personally invented happiness. "Papaya punch! My cousin made it. It's literally fire, you have to try it."

Maya took a sip. It tasted like sunscreen and artificial sweetness and something she couldn't name. "It's... interesting?"

"RIGHT?" Kevin yelled. "That's exactly what I said!"

Chloe swam over, her movements smooth and practiced. She pulled herself up to sit on the edge, water streaming from her hair. "Kevin, you know that's literally just Hawaiian Punch and expired sparkling water, right?"

"You ruin everything," Kevin said, splashing her before swimming away.

Maya laughed before she could stop herself. Chloe looked at her, really looked at her, for the first time all night. Maybe ever.

"What?" Maya said.

"Nothing." Chloe's slight smile deepened. "I just didn't know you laughed at stuff like that."

"What stuff?"

"You know. Dumb stuff." Chloe paused. "You always seem so serious. In English, when Ms. Rivera asked about symbolism in Gatsby, you had that whole thing about the green light being not just hope but—what was it?"

Maya stared at her. "You remember that?"

"I remember everything," Chloe said, then immediately looked like she wished she hadn't said it. "I mean, it was a good point. Better than anyone else made."

The pool lights flickered on as dusk settled, turning the water something glowing and impossible. Maya looked at Chloe—really looked at her too. The girl she'd spent four years thinking was untouchable, mysterious, some kind of sphinx she'd never solve. But Chloe wasn't a riddle. She was just a person sitting at the edge of a pool, wet hair dripping onto her shoulders, holding a cup of terrible punch.

"You know what?" Maya said, setting down her cup. She kicked off her flip-flops. "I think I will jump in."

Chloe's smile was real this time. "Finally."

Maya jumped. The water was perfect.