Riddle Me This
The kitchen hummed with low-key chaos. Someone's Bluetooth speaker was blasting that track everyone pretends to hate but secretly vibes to. I stood near the island, clutching a red Solo cup like it was a lifeline, watching Maya hold court from her spot on the counter.
"You coming?" Ethan asked, appearing beside me with that easy grin that made half the sophomore class simper.
"Eventually," I said, which was a lie. I'd been standing there for twenty minutes, working up the nerve to exist.
Then I saw it—Maya's **cat**,Paddington, perched atop the refrigerator like a furry god of judgment, yellow eyes fixed on me with what I swear was disdain. He looked like he knew something I didn't.
"What are you staring at?"
I jumped. Sofia had materialized, holding her phone like a shield. We'd been sort-of-friends since seventh grade, before she'd gotten all mysterious and aesthetic.
"The cat," I said. "He's judging me."
"Paddington judges everyone." She followed my gaze to Maya, then back to me. "You should talk to her."
"Sure," I said. "Right after I spontaneously develop social skills."
Sofia laughed, and it sounded genuine. "You're overthinking it. She's just a person. Albeit a person who dressed as a **sphinx** for Halloween and made it look iconic."
That's when it clicked. Why Maya was so intimidating—she moved through crowds like she was guarding secrets, like she'd ask you a riddle if you approached wrong. But that night in her living room, surrounded by peoplePerforming coolness, she was just Maya in a sequined dress, nursing a punch she'd spiked herself, checking her phone every five minutes.
"Hey," Sofia said, nudging me. "She's looking over here."
Maya wasn't looking at me, though. She was watching her little brother's **goldfish** bowl on the windowsill, where a single orange fish swam in endless, glittering circles. She looked sad, almost.
"You know," Sofia said quietly, "she had to move schools last year because her mom got sick. Nobody talks about it."
The kitchen suddenly felt different. Paddington blinked at me from the fridge, less judgmental now. The goldfish kept swimming, oblivious and free in its tiny universe.
"You think she's lonely?" I asked.
"I think," Sofia said, "that being mysterious is exhausting."
So I walked across the kitchen, past the island and the Solo cups and the low-key chaos, and said the first thing that came to mind: "Your fish has better social skills than I do."
Maya looked up, startled. Then she smiled—not her practiced cool-girl smile, but something real.
"Goldie's been working on his game," she said. "Want me to introduce you?"