Riddle at the Deep End
The hat was everything. A beat-up dad cap pulled low enough to hide my eyes, low enough to create a force field between me and everyone at Jordan's graduation pool party. I'd been standing by the snack table for forty minutes, nursing a lukewarm soda like it was my job.
"You gonna swim or what?" Jordan yelled from the pool, splashing water everywhere like an overexcited golden retriever. He'd already peeled off his shirt and was doing cannonballs off the diving board. Because Jordan was Jordan, and I was me, and some fundamental laws of the universe would shatter if I ever took off my shirt in public.
"Maybe later," I lied, adjusting my hat for the fiftieth time.
That's when I noticed her. The Sphinx. That's what everyone called Luna sophomore year after she'd spent three weeks sitting in the back of English class reading mythology without saying a single word. She was perched on the edge of the pool, legs dangling in the water, wearing this oversized sun hat that somehow looked intentional instead of ridiculous.
She caught me staring.
"Nice hat," she said, and I couldn't tell if she was being sarcastic or not. The Sphinx's riddle, apparently.
"Thanks," I said. "Yours too."
She patted the empty spot beside her. "Water's actually decent. Jordan shocked it yesterday, which is honestly the most responsible thing he's done since I've known him."
I sat. Kept my hat on. Kept my shirt on. Dangled my feet in the water and felt that perfect temperature difference—not too cold, not too warm, like the pool had been waiting for me specifically.
"I hate swimming," Luna said suddenly, watching Jordan attempt a handstand and immediately tip over. "My mom signed me up for lessons every summer from age five to twelve. I never learned. I just spent six years developing a really convincing fake-drowning technique."
I laughed. It slipped out before I could stop it.
"What?" She grinned, and it transformed her whole face. "That's genuinely funny to you?"
"No, it's just—" I gestured helplessly at the pool. "I've been standing over there for forty minutes coming up with excuses not to swim, and you've been sitting here the whole time also not swimming, and neither of us actually had to say it out loud until now."
"Fair." She studied me for a moment. Behind me, someone started a splash fight. "So what's the hat for? Bad hair day, or deep-seated insecurity?"
"Both," I said. "Also it completes my whole mysterious loner aesthetic."
"Tragic. Very brooding." She splashed water at my legs. "You know Jordan's going to drag you in eventually, right?"
"I know."
"So we have options." Luna counted on her fingers. "One: we maintain our dignity and let him try. Two: we go in on our terms and deny him the satisfaction. Three: we actually don't go in and I tell you about the time I accidentally won a riddle contest at the Renaissance Faire."
I looked at my reflection in the water—hat, anxious expression, all of it.
"Option two," I said, and stood up.
Luna's smile was real this time. "Race you to the deep end."
"You're on, Sphinx."
I took off my hat. Set it on the pool edge. Jumped into the water, fully clothed, without overthinking it for the first time in years.
Jordan cheered like I'd just won Olympic gold.
Luna splashed me in the face. "Better watch your back. I'm secretly a mermaid."
"Prove it," I said, splashing back.
Some riddles don't need answers. Sometimes you just have to jump in.