Papaya Sunset
The papaya sat on the kitchen counter like a mistake I couldn't take back. Mom had bought it because apparently that's what 'cultured families' eat now, but we both knew it was another attempt to make us seem less like the family that shops at Aldi with a reusable bag full of holes.
"You're not wearing that, are you?" I asked Maya, gesturing at the orange monstrosity she called a dress.
She spun around, her hair—freshly dyed a color that could only be described as 'unemployed mermaid'—whipping across her face. "It's vintage, Cassie. And you're just jealous because you're wearing jeans to a party. Again."
The party was at Tyler's house, which already had my stomach doing backflips. Tyler, who sat behind me in pre-calc and smelled like expensive cologne and poor life choices. Tyler, who once asked if I was going to the winter formal and then immediately said "never mind, I remember you're not really into that stuff."
I wasn't. But I also wasn't into being the girl who didn't get asked.
We walked to Tyler's because neither of us could drive and Maya refused to be seen in her dad's minivan. The August air was thick enough to chew on, and by the time we turned onto his street, the back of my neck was dripping. I could feel my hair frizzing into its natural state, which my mom lovingly called 'ethnic' and I called 'a tragedy.'
"You good?" Maya asked, eyeing me sideways.
"Fine. Just hot."
"You're nervous about Tyler."
"I'm not."
"You totally are. You've got that look you get when you're overthinking everything. Like that time you spent three hours analyzing why Kelsey didn't say hi back, even though she was wearing headphones."
I shoved her. But she wasn't wrong.
Tyler's backyard was already full of people I'd known since kindergarten but suddenly felt I didn't know at all. Someone had set up a slip-n-slide near the pool, and a group of guys I'd sat with at lunch since seventh grade were now shirtless and wet, laughing like they'd invented joy itself.
Then I saw Tyler. He was standing by the pool with red Solo cup in hand, looking effortless in a way that felt almost offensive. His hair was damp, pushed back from his face, and I hated how good he looked. I hated how badly I wanted him to look at me.
He didn't.
Instead, I spent the next hour pressed against a wall, nursing a cup of water that had gone warm, watching everyone else have the kind of night that would become core memories. Maya was somewhere near the slip-n-slide, her orange dress now soaked through, laughing with the kind of abandon I couldn't access.
I thought about leaving. I thought about walking home and texting Maya that I'd gotten sick. I thought about how much easier everything was before I started wanting things I couldn't have.
Then someone accidentally knocked into me, and my water splashed all over my white shirt.
Perfect. Absolutely perfect.
I marched to the bathroom, locked the door, and stared at myself in the mirror. Wet spot on my chest, frizzy hair, eyes swimming in tears I refused to let fall. I looked ridiculous. I felt ridiculous.
Someone knocked on the door. "Occupied," I called.
"Cassie?" It was Maya. "Open up."
I did. She was soaked, her hair plastered to her face, her orange dress dripping water onto the tile floor. Behind her, Tyler stood looking concerned.
"You okay?" he asked. "You've been in here a while."
The ridiculousness of it all hit me suddenly. I was in a bathroom at a party I didn't want to be at, crying over a guy who didn't know I existed, while my best friend looked like a drowned pumpkin and the object of my affection stood awkwardly in the doorway.
I started laughing. I couldn't help it.
"What?" Maya asked.
"I'm fine," I said, wiping my face. "Actually, I'm starving. Let's go find food."
We ended up on the curb outside, sharing the papaya I'd stolen from my kitchen earlier. It was mushy and weird and nothing like what either of us expected, but we sat there eating it with our hands while Tyler and his friends played beer pong in the distance.
"This is gross," Maya said, licking juice from her thumb.
"Yeah. But it's real."
"You're so weird."
"I know."
We sat there until my mom picked us up, two girls with orange-stained fingers and frizzy hair, eating a papaya that symbolized everything we were trying to figure out—how to be ourselves in a world that wanted something else.