← All Stories

Papaya Kings and Party Fails

hatbearpapaya

The papaya sat on the paper plate like an alien planet—orange, slimy, and totally suspicious. Around me, Jordan's basement thudded with bass that I could feel in my chest, but I was stuck in the kitchen doorway, paralyzed by a piece of fruit and the fact that my stupid beanie had somehow fallen into the chip bowl.

"You gonna eat that or just stare at it?"

I jumped. Maya leaned against the doorframe, all effortless cool in her cutoffs and that vintage band tee she'd worn to school twice this week. Maya, who'd sat behind me in bio since September and whose laugh I'd memorized without even trying.

"I'm... thinking about it?" That came out more like a question. Smooth, Leo. Real smooth.

She laughed. Not the fake one she gave teachers. The real one. "It's papaya, not a math test. Try it."

The papaya incident started last week when Carlos bet me I wouldn't eat something exotic at his party. Naturally, I'd agreed, because seventeen years of life had taught me exactly nothing about saying no to stupid dares. Now here I was: papaya-facing.

I took a bite. Sweet. Weirdly musky. Not terrible?

"Well?" Maya raised an eyebrow.

"It's... not awful?"

"High praise from the guy who survived the cafeteria's mystery meat Monday." She stepped closer, and my brain short-circuited. "You know, you're kind of brave for trying new things."

Brave. Me. The guy who'd spent three months working up the courage to just say hi to her properly.

"I, uh, lost my hat earlier," I blurted. "In the chips."

Maya grinned, and something shifted in her expression—something warm and interested and maybe just a little bit like she'd been waiting for me to mess up adorably. "I know. I saw. It was kind of cute."

The bass dropped somewhere in the other room. Someone whooped. But I just stood there, papaya half-eaten, heart doing something ridiculous in my chest.

"So," Maya said, pushing off the doorframe. "Wanna get out of here? There's a food truck downtown. They serve bear-shaped waffles."

I almost dropped my papaya.

"Only if you never tell anyone about the chip bowl hat thing."

"Deal." She held out her hand. "Come on, Papaya Boy. Let's bounce."

I grabbed my jacket and her hand, and somewhere between the kitchen and the front door, I realized: maybe trying new things wasn't so bad after all.