← All Stories

Papaya & Curveballs

papayaspybaseballcat

Lila's phone buzzed against her nightstand at 2 AM. Again.

She groaned, face-planting into her pillow. Captain Whiskers—her fat orange tabby cat—responded by kneading dough on her lower back with claws that felt like tiny daggers.

"Dude, stop," she mumbled, shoving him gently. The cat yowled his opinion of this treatment and stalked toward the kitchen.

Lila grabbed her phone, stomach doing that stupid fluttery thing it always did when THAT NAME lit up her screen.

**Ethan:** u awake?

Of course he was. Ethan Reynolds, starting pitcher for the varsity baseball team, the guy who'd somehow become her lab partner in AP Bio, the human equivalent of a golden retriever in a letterman jacket. They'd been texting for three weeks now, ever since he'd helped her pick up dropped beakers and somehow ended up carrying her books to her next period.

She shouldn't have felt like such a spy every time his name popped up. She wasn't infiltrating his life. They were friends. Sort of. Maybe.

**Lila:** literally never

**Ethan:** lol fair. can't sleep

**Lila:** big game tomorrow?

**Ethan:** yeah. nervous af

Lila smiled into the dark. Ethan Reynolds, nervous? The guy who threw a no-hitter against their rival school last month?

**Ethan:** hey random question

Her heart kicked against her ribs.

**Ethan:** what's ur favorite fruit

Lila stared at her ceiling fan spinning lazy circles. What?

**Lila:** um... strawberries? why?

**Ethan:** nice

**Ethan:** my mom went to this exotic market and bought all this weird stuff

**Ethan:** she insisted i try this papaya thing

**Ethan:** it tastes like straight-up vomit

Lila snorted so loud Captain Whiskers puffed up like a bottle brush from his spot in the doorway.

**Lila:** you're literally insane

**Ethan:** i'm saving you from making the same mistake i did

**Ethan:** consider it a public service announcement

**Lila:** very generous of you ethan reynolds

**Ethan:** i try

**Ethan:** anyway i'll let you sleep

**Ethan:** sweet dreams strawberry girl

Lila's face burned in the darkness. Strawberry girl? Really?

But she was still smiling when her eyes finally closed.

The next afternoon, Lila stood in the bleachers surrounded by what felt like the entire school. The air smelled like dirt, sunscreen, and that metallic tang you only found at baseball fields. Her friends were crowded around her, screaming whenever someone from their team made contact with the ball.

Lila just watched Ethan on the mound, the way he adjusted his cap between pitches, the focused intensity that made him look different than the goofy guy who texted her about weird fruit at 2 AM.

"You're staring," said Maya, her best friend since kindergarten, smirking sideways.

"I am not," Lila said, definitely staring.

"Girl, you've been lowkey obsessed since he became your lab partner. Just talk to him already."

"We talk all the time," Lila defended, which sounded weak even to her own ears.

"ABOUT PAPAYA," Maya said. "That's not talking, that's weird agricultural trivia."

Before Lila could defend her honor as an agricultural trivia enthusiast, Ethan wound up and threw something that made the batter swing so hard he almost spun himself into the ground.

"STRIKE THREE!" the umpire bellowed.

The crowd went absolutely feral. Her friends were jumping up and down, screaming themselves hoarse, and somehow in the chaos Lila found herself swept down the stairs toward the field. Players spilled out of the dugout, parents rushed the fence, everything was noise and motion and sunshine.

And then somehow she was near the front, and Ethan had just finished high-fiving his teammates, and he looked up and their eyes locked.

He grinned—that same grin from her phone screen, real and three-dimensional and ten times more overwhelming—and jogged over.

"Hey," he said, slightly out of breath, sweat matting his hair to his forehead.

"Nice game," Lila managed, which was the most boring sentence ever spoken but also her brain had temporarily ceased function.

"Thanks." He ducked his head, weirdly shy for someone who'd just struck out three people in a row. "Hey, so I was thinking..."

A girl with perfectly curled hair and a varsity jacket appeared at his elbow. "Ethan! Party at my place to celebrate! You coming?"

Ethan glanced between them, and Lila's stomach dropped through the bleachers. This was it. The part where the popular girl showed up and Lila remembered exactly where she fit in this particular hierarchy.

"Actually," Ethan said, "I was gonna ask Lila if she wanted to hang out."

The girl blinked. Taken aback. Lila felt her own jaw unhinge.

"Oh," the girl said. "Cool. I guess." She drifted away toward a group of equally polished-looking people.

Ethan turned back to Lila, scratching the back of his neck like he hadn't just broken social laws. "So, that was weird. Anyway—I was gonna say, there's this food truck downtown that supposedly has amazing smoothies, and I wanted someone to test if their papaya one is actually good or if I just hate papaya in general. Scientific method, you know?"

Lila stared at him. The boy who threw curveballs at 75 miles per hour, who could've gone to any party with anyone he wanted, was asking her to conduct a fruit experiment with him.

Captain Whiskers would never believe this.

"Yes," she said, maybe a little too quickly. "Like, for science."

"Exactly. Science." He grinned, and it was even better up close. "I'll meet you by the parking lot in twenty? I just have to do the whole post-game thing first."

"Deal."

As he jogged toward his coach, Maya appeared beside Lila, eyes wide. "Did that just happen?"

"I think so," Lila said, barely recognizing her own voice.

"Papaya," Maya said solemnly. "He remembered your text from last night. He's flirting with you about papaya."

Lila watched Ethan laugh at something his teammate said, his easy confidence, the way he kept glancing back toward the bleachers like he was checking she was still there.

"Yeah," she said, warmth spreading through her chest. "I guess he is."

Her phone buzzed in her pocket.

**Ethan:** don't leave without me

**Ethan:** promise the smoothies will be better than texting about them

Lila smiled down at her screen, papaya and baseball and cats and whatever-this-was colliding into something entirely new.

**Lila:** you better not be wrong about the papaya

Some curveballs, she decided, were absolutely worth swinging for.