← All Stories

Out of Left Field

papayagoldfishbaseballfox

Maya's summer job at Snack Shack Paradise was supposed to be easy. Scoop ice cream, hand out towels, maybe flirt with the baseball players from the travel league. But standing there in her polyester uniform that smelled like fake coconut, she felt like the world's most awkward human.

"You gonna slice that papaya all day, Maya?" Jake Sanders called from the batting cage. Her stomach did that ridiculous flutter thing it always did when he spoke. Jake, with his perfect swing and his effortless confidence and his hair that fell in his face when he laughed.

"She's admiring the tropical aesthetic," chirped Chloe, who worked the register and had already appointed herself Maya's summer mentor. "Just like she was admiring your home run yesterday."

Maya's face burned. "I was not."

"You so were. I saw you." Chloe grinned. "But heads up—fox alert at three o'clock."

Riley, the girl who'd made Maya's freshman year absolute hell, sauntered toward the shack. Riley with her designer sneakers and her knowing smirk and her ability to make everything Maya said sound wrong. The nickname "the fox" had started as a joke but stuck because it was too perfect—sly and pretty and dangerous if you turned your back.

"Interesting choice for a summer gig," Riley said, sliding onto a stool. "Very... you."

Maya's grip tightened on the knife. "What's that supposed to mean?"

"Oh, you know." Riley waved a hand like she was brushing away a tiny, invisible bug. "Just that you always pick the weirdest stuff. Remember when you brought that goldfish to school in a water bottle? The one you won at the carnival and then cried about when it died two days later?"

The baseball team went quiet. Someone snorted. Maya's throat closed up.

"That was three years ago, Riley."

"I know. I'm just saying—you're still that girl. Still doing weird stuff." Riley leaned in. "Still obsessed with Jake."

The baseball paused. Maya's heart hammered against her ribs. She waited for Jake to say something, to deny it, to laugh. But he just stood there, baseball in hand, staring at his cleats like they were suddenly the most fascinating things on earth.

Something in Maya shifted. Maybe it was the humidity. Maybe it was Riley's smirk. Maybe it was suddenly seeing Jake not as her crush but as another person who wouldn't step up.

"Actually," Maya said slowly, "I'm not that girl anymore. And Jake?" She sliced through the papaya with more force than necessary. "He's just some guy who hits balls with a stick."

Jake's head snapped up. Riley's mouth actually fell open.

"What?" Chloe whispered.

"You heard me." Maya placed the fruit slices on a plate with deliberate calm. "Anyone want papaya? It's actually pretty good if you stop acting like trying new things is weird."

The baseball team exchanged glances. Jake took a step toward the shack. Then another. He grabbed his glove from the fence and kept walking until he stood right in front of her counter.

"I like papaya," he said. "And I thought you were at the game yesterday because you like baseball. Not because of me."

Behind him, Riley rolled her eyes. "Whatever. This is boring."

As she walked away, Maya realized her hands weren't shaking anymore. Jake was still standing there, waiting for an answer.

"I do like baseball," she said. "But I also like not being the person everyone expects me to be."

Jake smiled then—a real one, not the practiced grin he used after a good hit. "Yeah? What's that like?"

Maya sliced another piece of papaya. "Come back after practice and I'll show you."

Chloe whooped. The baseball team hollered. And Maya thought maybe this summer wouldn't be so bad after all.