← All Stories

Orange Peel Alibis

iphonespyorange

Maya's fingers hovered over the screen of her cracked iPhone 11, the one she'd begged her mom for since seventh grade. Now, at fifteen, it felt less like a prize and more like a tracking device. Her best friend Chloe had texted something cryptic: 'u need to see this. NOW.'

Maya crept down the hallway, past her parents' bedroom where dad snored like a broken lawnmower. The kitchen clock glowed 2:17 AM. She was supposed to be at Jordan's house 'studying,' which technically wasn't a total lie—they'd studied each other's playlists for three hours before Jordan leaned in and Maya's brain had short-circuited.

Now Chloe's Snapchat story was blowing up with screenshots of someone's Instagram DMs. Maya's stomach did that thing where it felt like she'd swallowed a whole orange peel—spikey and wrong. Because those DMs were from Jordan. To some girl named Taylor from the rival high school. 'Friday's gonna be lit,' he'd written. 'bring that orange crop top ; )'

Maya threw her phone onto her bed like it burned. Was she a spy now? Was this what relationships were? She'd never even had a real boyfriend before, unless you counted that one week in eighth grade when Lucas held her hand during a fire drill and then immediately stopped talking to her forever.

Her phone buzzed. Jordan: 'can't stop thinking about earlier'

Maya stared at the message until the words blurred. 'Same,' she typed back, even though her hands were shaking. 'Friday still on?'

'yea. why wouldn't it be?'

'No reason.'

She pulled up Chloe's story again. The timestamp on the DMs was from three weeks ago—before Jordan even knew Maya existed. The orange crop top message made sense now. Taylor was his cousin who went to that other school. Chloe had captioned the screenshots 'tea ☕️' but obviously didn't know the full context.

Maya's face burned. She'd almost sabotaged everything because she'd let her insecurities turn her into some paranoid, iPhone-stalking spy. That's what happened when you grew up on Instagram comparisons and TikTok relationship advice—you forgot how to trust anything real.

She grabbed an orange from the kitchen counter on her way back to bed, peeled it in the dark. The citrus smell cut through everything. Tomorrow she'd tell Jordan about her almost-meltdown. He'd laugh, but not in a mean way. Maybe vulnerability was the real risk, not trusting people.

Her phone lit up again: Jordan had posted a new story. It was just a blurry pic of his ceiling with the caption 'can't sleep'

Maya smiled and typed: 'me neither'

Some things were simpler than she made them out to be.