← All Stories

No Cap, Just Real

hatbaseballpool

The stupid **hat** sat on my nightstand, mocking me. It was a washed-out navy **baseball** cap with the Curly W logo—Finn's lucky cap, the one he'd worn every varsity game since freshman year. The one I'd secretly "borrowed" after Friday's party and hadn't returned yet.

I stood in front of my mirror, running a hand through my freshly buzzed hair. Mom's voice echoed from downstairs: "Jordan! The **pool** party starts in twenty!"

I threw on Finn's cap. It smelled like him—coconut shampoo and something woodsy. My stomach did that nervous flutter thing, the same one from when we'd almost held hands during last week's horror movie.

The McKennas' backyard was already chaos when I arrived. Teens everywhere—some cannonballing into the **pool**, others sprawled on beach chairs blasting Doja Cat. And there, shirtless and gorgeous near the diving board, was Finn. My breath hitched.

His eyes locked on me instantly. Then on the cap. He grinned.

"Yo, Jordan!" he called, striding over. "Is that—"

I flushed. "Yeah. Sorry, I meant to give it back—"

"Nah, keep it." His dimples showed. "Looks better on you anyway."

My brain short-circuited. "Wait, really?"

He stepped closer, water still dripping from his hair. "I've been trying to get your attention since September, Jordan. You borrowing my stuff? That's progress."

Behind us, someone shouted: "WIFFLE BALL! Who's playing?"

Finn's eyes lit up. "You any good at **baseball**?"

I shrugged. "My dad tried. I mostly struck out. A lot."

"Perfect." Finn grabbed my hand. "You're on my team."

The sun baked my shoulders as we played, his lucky cap now officially mine. I caught a pop fly. He high-fived me, his hand lingering. My heart hammered like crazy.

Later, we sat on the **pool** edge, feet in the water. The cap lay beside us.

"So," Finn said, "homecoming's next month."

I turned. His expression was nervous but determined.

"You gonna ask me properly," I said, "or keep dropping hints?"

He laughed, splashing water. "Jordan Torres, will you go to homecoming with me?"

"No cap?" I teased.

"No cap." He leaned in.

The kiss tasted like chlorine and possibility. And somewhere on the concrete, the navy **baseball** cap sat between us, no longer just Finn's or mine—but ours.