← All Stories

Green Between the Teeth

bullspinachwater

The pool party at Tyler's house was supposed to be Maya's social resurrection. Freshman year had been a disaster of invisibility, but sophomore year was going to be different. She'd spent three hours picking out an outfit that said "I'm chill but also I have a personality."

Now she stood at the edge of the pool, clutching her red Solo cup like it was a life raft, while Tyler held court in the deep end. He was loud, surrounded by friends, telling some story about how he almost fought a senior at the skate park.

"That's such **bull**," someone muttered behind her.

Maya turned to see Leo, the quiet guy from her English class who always sat in the back and drew in his notebook. He was watching Tyler with this expression of mild amusement, like Tyler was a sitcom he'd seen too many episodes of.

"What?" Maya asked, then immediately regretted it. Why did she say anything? Now she was committed to a conversation she didn't know how to have.

"Tyler didn't almost fight anyone," Leo said, quiet enough that only she could hear. "He saw that senior from across the parking lot and walked the other way. I was there. But you know how it is—the story gets better every time he tells it."

Maya thought about how much energy she spent curating her own stories, carefully editing her life into something worth posting about. "Why do people do that?"

Leo shrugged. "Because real life's boring. And if you admit you're scared, you're basically admitting you're not who everyone thinks you are."

They stood there for a minute, watching the chaotic splash fight in the pool. The chlorine smell was starting to give Maya a headache. She took a sip from her cup—just tap **water**, because she didn't do soda anymore after her dentist gave her that lecture about enamel erosion, which had been humiliating.

"Hey," Leo said suddenly. "You got—" He gestured to his own teeth.

Maya froze. "What?"

"**Spinach**. From the veggie tray. It's... pretty noticeable."

Her face burned. She'd been walking around with green in her teeth for who knows how long, trying to look effortless and chill, and she'd looked ridiculous the whole time. She started to turn away, to run to the bathroom, but Leo caught her arm.

"I mean it—it's okay. Everyone's got something. Last week, I walked around all day with my shirt inside out. Didn't notice until seventh period when Maya Rodriguez literally couldn't stop laughing."

Something about the way he said it made Maya actually laugh. Not the polite, compressed-lip laugh she used around new people, but a real laugh that made her shoulders drop two inches.

"Thanks for telling me," she said. "Most people would've just let me embarrass myself."

"I figured you'd want to know," Leo said. "Besides, Tyler's been telling that fake story for twenty minutes and nobody's called him out yet. Sometimes you need someone to tell you the truth."

Maya looked at Tyler, still holding court in the water, then back at Leo, who was already walking away. "Hey," she called out. "You want to get some food? That veggie tray's obviously dangerous."

Leo turned back, and for the first time, he really smiled. "Yeah. Actually, I do."