← All Stories

Green Between the Teeth

baseballwaterrunningspinach

The seventh-inning stretch couldn't come fast enough. I'd been staring at Josh from across the bleachers for forty-five minutes—ever since he'd slid into home plate and his baseball jersey had ridden up just enough to reveal that ridiculous hipbone situation that made my stomach do actual cartwheels.

"You're literally drooling," Maya said, elbowing me. "Just go talk to him."

"I literally can't," I hissed back. "I'm still recovering from last week's TikTok incident where I thought I was being all mysterious and artsy but the audio didn't sync and I looked like I was having a seizure."

"Bro, nobody remembers that."

"My sister showed it to the entire dinner table on Sunday. My grandma asked if I needed an exorcism."

The game dragged on. I decided I'd finally make my move during the next break, casually walk past him like I was heading to the concessions, maybe drop something legendary like 'nice slide' or 'you play good' (yes, I know that's grammatically wrong, but nervousness makes me stupid).

The buzzer finally sounded. I stood up, heart suddenly running a marathon against my ribs. This was it. I adjusted my crop top, checked my reflection in my phone camera—

And froze.

There, visible from space, a massive piece of spinach wedged between my front teeth like some kind of demonic vegetable sentinel. I'd eaten a spinach wrap before the game. HOW LONG had it been there? Had I been smiling at Josh with spinach in my teeth for forty-five minutes?

"Maya," I whispered. "Maya, oh my god."

She turned, looked, and immediately lost it. Cackling. Full-on shoulder-shaking, tears-flowing laughter.

"How long?" I demanded, already running toward the bathroom.

"The whole game!" she called after me. "You were sitting there making eyes at him like 'look at me, look at me' and it was RIGHT THERE!"

I burst into the bathroom and splashed water on my face, trying to rinse away the mortification. Then, because the universe hated me, someone walked in.

Josh. In his baseball uniform. Looking confused.

"This is the women's restroom," he said.

"I know," I said, mouth full of water because I'd just rinsed and couldn't spit yet. "I'm—"

I tried to swallow but choked instead. Water went everywhere. Down my chin, onto my shirt. I was a disaster. A wet, spinach-toothed disaster who was now choking in front of my crush.

He stared. Then—thank everything holy—he started laughing.

"You okay?"

I finally spit into the sink. "Never been better."

"You're that girl from the bleachers," he said. "The one who kept—"

"Please don't finish that sentence."

"—smiling at me," he finished, grinning. "It was kinda cute."

"With the spinach."

"Oh, the spinach was legendary." He leaned against the doorframe. "I was actually going to come over, but I had something in my teeth too, and I didn't want to be That Guy."

"Are you serious?"

"Sesame seeds from the bagel I ate this morning. I've been hiding them for six innings."

We looked at each other and started laughing. It wasn't romantic or magical or anything like the movies. It was two awkward people with food in their teeth, standing in a girls' bathroom while a baseball game continued without them.

"Want to get water after the game?" he asked. "I promise to check your teeth first."