← All Stories

Goldfish in the Deep End

spinachswimmingwatergoldfishpyramid

The pool party at Jessica's house was supposed to be legendary. Instead, I stood at the edge, clutching my towel like a lifeline, watching the social pyramid of our high school play out in the water. There they were — the popular kids forming the tip of the pyramid, splashing each other with the kind of effortless confidence I'd been trying to fake since seventh grade.

"You coming in or what?" Marcus called from the deep end. He was that guy — varsity swim team, hair that somehow looked better wet, and a smile that made my stomach do weird things I refused to examine.

"Yeah, just," I mumbled, then remembered: I'd had that spinach smoothie for lunch. I bolted for the bathroom mirror, frantically checking my teeth. Nothing. I let out a breath I didn't know I'd been holding.

By the time I made it to the pool, everyone had migrated to the shallow end, gathered around something small and orange. A goldfish — one of those carnival prizes that usually dies within three days — was swimming in frantic circles near the surface.

"It's struggling," someone said.

"It's a fish," Marcus replied, but he was already reaching for it.

I found myself kneeling beside him, our hands almost touching as we cupped the tiny creature together. The goldfish's scales flashed in the sunlight, a burst of color in the chlorinated water.

"We should put it somewhere better," I said, surprising myself.

Marcus looked at me, really looked at me, and for once I didn't feel like the awkward girl who overthought everything. "My neighbor has a pond."

"Bet," I said, because apparently that's what normal people said now.

We spent the next hour walking to his neighbor's house, water dripping from our clothes, carrying the goldfish in a red solo cup. Marcus told me about how he hated being the swim team star, how he just wanted to paint. I told him about my blog where I reviewed bizarre smoothie combinations.

"Spinach was definitely a mistake," I admitted.

He laughed, and it was the most genuine sound I'd heard all day.

Back at the party, Jessica took one look at us and made a face. "You guys have been gone forever."

"Goldfish rescue mission," Marcus said, sliding his hand into mine like it was the most natural thing in the world.

The pyramid had shifted. Maybe I hadn't climbed it — maybe I'd just realized I didn't want to be at the top anymore. Sometimes the best things happen when you stop swimming toward where everyone else is going and just let yourself float.