← All Stories

Goldfish in the Deep End

lightninggoldfishpoolpalmbaseball

The carnival goldfish bag was sweating against my palm, plastic threatening to burst. I'd won it playing that rigged baseball toss game—threw three strikes and somehow still snagged a tiny orange fish swimming in circles.

"You coming in or what?" Tyler called from the pool.

I froze. Tyler Martinez. Starting pitcher. Instagram stories always filled with golden-hour photos that made my chest do that weird fluttery thing. My bare feet gripped the concrete deck.

Behind me, actual thunder rumbled. The sky had turned that bruised purple color—summer storm incoming. A streak of lightning cracked the horizon, electric and sudden.

"Storm's coming!" someone yelled.

Everyone started scrambling out of the water, towels flying, laughter mixing with the first heavy drops. I stood there holding my fish like an idiot while Tyler pulled himself up the ladder, water streaming off him.

He stopped. "Is that a goldfish?"

"Yeah," I managed. "Won it. Don't ask."

Tyler laughed, and it was this genuine thing that crinkled his eyes. "That's honestly so random. What are you gonna name it?"

"I—uh—haven't thought about it."

"Rookie," he said, grinning. "Hey, you wanna bail before we get soaked? My house is like two minutes."

My palm went clammy against the plastic bag. "Yeah. Okay."

We ran through the first real rain of the summer, the goldfish sloshing in its tiny prison, and I realized I'd never been more terrified in my life.

Tyler caught my eye as we ducked under his porch overhang. "Nice throw today, by the way. At the carnival. You've got an arm."

I looked down at the fish, now swimming calmly through the chaos of our run. "Thanks," I said, and somehow, standing there in a thunderstorm with a goldfish I hadn't planned on, I felt like maybe I was exactly where I was supposed to be.