Goldfish in My Teeth
The problem with being sixteen is that everything feels like the end of the world, even when it's just spinach stuck in your teeth at Tyler Morrison's party.
I'd been leaning against the kitchen island for twenty minutes, nursing my orange soda and trying to look like I belonged, when Maya finally found me.
"You look like a zombie," she said, grinning. "Did you actually sleep last night, or did you just binge-watch that show until dawn again?"
"I slept," I lied. I'd been up until 3 AM overthinking whether to text Tyler back, which was pathetic because we'd been talking for like three weeks and he still hadn't asked me to homecoming.
Maya stole my drink and took a sip. "So, Tyler's hosting this whole thing because his parents went to some cabin. Apparently there's a bear that keeps coming onto their property up there. His dad's obsessed with it. Has like, trail cams and everything."
"A bear?" I raised an eyebrow. "Sounds fake."
"Swear to god." She nudged my arm. "Speaking of Tyler, he's literally looking at you right now."
I froze. In that moment, I made a split-second decision to be bold, to cross the room and actually talk to him like a normal person with social skills. I pushed off the counter, my heart doing that thing where it forgot how to beat properly.
Then I tripped.
My orange soda went everywhere. All over Tyler's white carpet. All over his shoes. Some splashed onto his jeans.
The room went quiet. Like, zombie apocalypse quiet.
Tyler stared at the spreading orange stain, then up at me, and—this was the worst part—he started laughing.
"Nice entrance," he said. "You know, I have a goldfish who's less graceful than you."
"Your goldfish trips people?" I shot back, my face burning.
"Metaphorically." He grinned. "His name is Captain Fin. He judges me from his bowl."
And somehow, we were talking. Really talking. About his judgmental goldfish, about my irrational fear of zombies (don't ask), about how much we both hated when our parents tried to force us to eat spinach because it was "brain food."
"I bet you're great at avoiding things you don't want to deal with," he said, his voice dropping lower.
"I'm avoiding asking you to homecoming right now," I blurted out.
His eyes widened. Then he smiled—really smiled, like I'd just made his entire life better. "I was avoiding asking you too."
Later, as we sat on his back porch watching the sun come up, orange streaking across the sky like someone had spilled paint, I thought about how I'd spent weeks overthinking everything. How I'd felt like a zombie going through the motions of high school, terrified of every awkward moment.
Turns out the awkward moments were the whole point. The spills, the terrible jokes, the ridiculous conversations—they were what made things real.
"Hey," Tyler said, bumping my shoulder. "You still have some spinach in your teeth from earlier."
I laughed until I couldn't breathe. Some nights really do change everything.