Goldfish in My Palm
The party was already mid when Maya arrived, fashionably late but internally screaming. She'd spent forty-five minutes picking an outfit, only to throw on her dad's old beanie hat at the last second because her hair was doing something weird. Hiding under the brim felt safer somehow.
"Maya! You made it!" Jordan called from the kitchen, gesturing with a red cup. "Chase is by the patio doors."
Her stomach did that thing it always did when she heard Chase's name. Half excitement, half terror, 100% teenage mess.
She made her way through the crowded living room, dodging dancing bodies and hoping her sweaty palms weren't obvious. She'd practiced what to say all week. Hi. Hey. What's up. Cool party. Everything sounded completely unhinged in her head.
She found him leaning against the doorframe, laughing at something. Then he saw her and smiled. For real.
"Hey, Maya," Chase said. "I like the hat."
Her brain short-circuited. She tried to respond coolly, but what came out was something like "Thanks it's my dad's but not really but kind of."
He laughed. Not in a mean way. In a way that made her face burn.
"Want some spinach dip?" he asked, gesturing to a bowl on the counter. "It's actually not terrible."
"Sure," she managed, reaching for a chip. This was fine. This was normal.
Then came the moment that would live in infamy. They talked for like twenty minutes about video games and how much they both hated pre-calc, and she actually felt like herself, like maybe she didn't have to perform a version of herself to be liked. Then she went to the bathroom and caught her reflection.
Spinach. A massive, unmistakable piece of spinach wedged between her front teeth. The entire conversation. The entire time.
She stared at herself in the mirror, wanting to evaporate. How many times had Chase looked at her teeth instead of her eyes? How many times had he been too polite to say something? She felt like that goldfish her sister won at the fair—the one that forgot everything every three seconds and lived its whole confused life in a tiny bowl.
When she emerged from the bathroom, ready to fake a family emergency and never return to this school again, Chase was still there.
"Everything okay?" he asked.
Maya took a breath. "I had spinach in my teeth, didn't I?"
He grinned. "For like, half the conversation. But I didn't want to say anything and make it weird."
"You failed," she said, and they both laughed.
"Honestly," he said, "it was kind of a relief. I thought I was the only one overthinking everything."
They sat on the patio steps while the party continued inside, talking about nothing and everything until her mom picked her up at midnight. Maya pulled the hat lower to hide her smile, but something told her it didn't matter anymore.
Some nights, she learned, you leave with spinach in your teeth and a phone number in your pocket. And that, apparently, was what growing up felt like.