← All Stories

Goldfish in a Beanie

vitaminpalmgoldfishhat

The plastic bag sloshed against my palm as I stood there, frozen. Inside, a single goldfish - possibly the most doomed creature at Tyler's party - swam in tiny, panicked circles.

"You won?" Tyler materialized beside me, his snapback turned backward like he'd just stepped out of a TikTok. "Dude, that's actually kinda sick."

I mean, technically I HAD won. The carnival game in Tyler's backyard was rigged, but his little cousin was operating it and I guess she took pity on me. Or maybe she just wanted me to take the fish and leave.

"Yeah," I managed, my voice doing that embarrassing crack thing. "Super sick."

My other hand gripped the beanie I'd been wearing all night - my security blanket, basically. I'd only taken it off because the kitchen was literally ninety degrees and I could feel my hair turning into a frizz ball under there.

"You want me to hold that?" Tyler pointed at the fish bag. "You look like you're about to drop it."

Before I could respond, his hand brushed mine - skin contact, actual skin contact - and my palm went instantly sweaty. Not just damp, but like, full-on nervous moisture. The kind that makes you wonder if other people can SEE your anxiety.

He didn't seem to notice. Just transferred the fish bag to his own hand like it was no big deal, like people carried around random goldfish at parties every day.

"So," he said, leaning against the counter. "You gonna give it a name?"

I stared at him. Was this happening? Tyler Chen, who I'd been lowkey crushing on since September, was making conversation with me about a fish I'd accidentally won?

"Um," I said intelligently. "Maybe... Vitamin?"

"Vitamin?" Tyler raised an eyebrow, and I could see him trying not to laugh. "That's not a fish name."

"It's ironic," I rushed to explain, face burning. "You know, because fish don't take vitamins. And also my mom's always on me about taking my vitamin gummies, which I literally JUST remembered I forgot to take today, so..."

I stopped. I was rambling. I was literally rambling about vitamins to Tyler Chen while he held my goldfish.

But then he smiled - actually smiled, not the polite one he gave teachers or the fake one for Instagram posts. "Vitamin," he repeated. "Okay, I respect the chaotic energy. That fits."

The fish swam another anxious lap. My palm was still sweating against my jeans. But for some reason, I didn't want to put my beanie back on anymore.

"Hey," Tyler said, pushing off the counter. "Wanna help me find Vitamin somewhere to crash? I think my sister has an empty tank in her room."

And just like that, I was following Tyler Chen upstairs, feeling like maybe - just maybe - this goldfish was the best thing that had ever happened to me.