← All Stories

Goldfish at the Deep End

poolbearorangegoldfishbaseball

The first time I saw him, he was diving into the pool like a literal mermaid—well, a merman—except he had this bright orange swim cap that made him look like a traffic cone trying to swim laps.

"That's Chase," Maya whispered, like she was introducing me to a celebrity. "He's on the baseball team. Hit a home run last Friday."

I nodded like I knew what that meant, but honestly? I was too busy trying not to look like I was trying too hard. Standing there in my oversized t-shirt (because apparently my body decided to go through puberty at the most inconvenient possible time), I felt about as graceful as a goldfish flopping around on dry land.

The pool party was Lily's idea—her parents were out of town, and somehow twenty sophomores ended up in her backyard, most of us awkwardly holding red solo cups filled with Sprite because we were all too scared to touch the actual stuff.

Chase climbed out of the water, and okay, I saw what the hype was about. He had that whole athlete thing going on, but also kind of soft around the edges? Like a teddy bear that could also probably bench press me. Maya caught me staring and immediately started making kissy faces.

"Shut up," I hissed, but my face was doing that thing where it gets so red I basically look like a tomato.

"Go talk to him!" she pushed.

"I literally cannot breathe right now, so no."

But then somehow—still not sure how—there I was, standing next to him by the snack table, watching him aggressively peel an orange like his life depended on it.

"These things are impossible," he said, and I wanted to die because why was this so cute?

"You're doing it wrong," I heard myself say, and then I proceeded to demonstrate proper orange-peeling technique because apparently that was my personality now.

He laughed, and I felt it in my toes.

"You're weird," he said. "I like that."

And later, when everyone else was doing cannonballs and playing chicken fight, me and Chase sat on the pool edge with our feet in the water, talking about everything and nothing, while somewhere behind us, someone accidentally knocked over the goldfish bowl and suddenly there were fish everywhere.

"Should we help?" I asked.

"Nah," he said, pulling his feet out and splashing water on my legs. "Let them figure it out."

I smiled. "You're terrible."

"Yeah," he grinned. "But you like that."

And honestly? I really, really did.