Fake It 'Til You Make It
Maya smoothed the faux-fur hat over her frizz halo for the third time. The house party thumped with bass that vibrated in her chest, but she felt like she was watching everything through a glass wall. Junior year was supposed to be her glow-up era, but mostly she was just anxious.
"You good?" Liam asked, appearing beside her with two red Solo cups. He'd somehow managed to turn his awkward middle school phase into TikTok fame, while Maya was still trying to figure out who she was supposed to be.
"Just peacing out," she said, though they'd only been there twenty minutes. Her phone buzzed—her mom wondering why she wasn't home yet.
Outside, the summer air smelled like someone's dad grilling something experimental. Maya spotted Carter's ancient station wagon—his family called it The Bear because it hibernated in their driveway for months at a time. Freshmen warned it was haunted. Maya just thought it was tragic.
She pulled out her iPhone, thumb hovering over Carter's contact. They'd been texting for weeks, all late-night memes and "are you thinking what I'm thinking" energy that made her stomach do little flip things. But tonight he hadn't said a single word to her face.
"Papaya," a voice said behind her.
Maya jumped. Carter stood there, holding a fruit cup like it was a peace offering. "It's the only thing I can eat without dying. My mom's basically a conspiracy theorist about allergies now."
"Oh," she said brilliantly. "Cool."
"Cool," he echoed, then ruined it by adding, "or not. I mean, it's NOT cool. Having the diet of a toddler is definitely mid." He grinned, and this was new—texting Carter was confident and flirty, but real Carter was kind of a mess.
Maya felt herself smiling back. "My hat's from the kids' section. I'm technically a size small but it's fine, we don't have to talk about it."
His eyes lit up. "No way. I found these socks at Target—"
"With the little foxes on them?"
"How did you KNOW?"
"You posted them," she said. "Three times."
"Right," he laughed. "Right. I forgot I'm chronically online."
The bass from the party muffled into the background. They talked about nothing important—his grandma's terrible cooking, her fear of public speaking, why algebra should be illegal. For the first time all night, Maya's chest wasn't tight.
"Hey," Carter said eventually. "I was gonna ask if you wanted to—"
"CARTER!" someone yelled from the porch. "Beer pong! You're up!"
He winced. "Duty calls. But um, I'll text you? Like, actually text you. Not just leave you on read for three hours while I overthink emojis."
"I'd like that," she said, and realized she meant it.
As he walked back to the party, Maya touched her hat. It wasn't the perfect outfit. This wasn't the perfect night. But maybe that was okay. Maybe real life was messier than the curated version she'd been trying to perform.
She pulled out her phone and texted her mom: staying a bit longer. Everything's fine. Everything's good.