Breaking the Surface
The backward baseball cap was Marcus's armor. He'd been wearing it since quitting the team three weeks ago, brim flipped up like he was still the pitcher with the nasty curveball, still the guy everyone counted on. Now he was just the guy who'd bailed.
Jessica's pool party glittered with everything he was avoiding: the baseball team in their collective reminiscence about the season they'd almost won, the way Jenna kept looking at him like she wanted to ask why, why, why he'd walked away.
Marcus leaned against the fence, nursing a lukewarm soda. The pool reflected fractured summer light, kids cannonballing and screaming. His phone buzzed—baseball group chat blowing up about someone getting recruited. Once, that would've been him running toward a future instead of away from it.
"You gonna hide all night?" Jenna materialized beside him, water dripping from her swimsuit straps. She'd always seen through the cap.
"I'm not hiding."
"You're literally standing behind a bush."
Marcus cracked a smile despite himself. "Strategic positioning."
"Marcus." Her voice softened. "Coach said you could come back."
"I don't want back." He traced the cap's embroidered logo. "I don't even know if I ever wanted it at all."
The truth hung between them—he'd played because his dad played, because it was what you did in this town, because throwing a perfect game felt easier than figuring out who he was when he wasn't throwing anything.
Jenna splashed him.
"Hey!"
"Take off the hat, Marcus."
"What?"
"The hat. Take it off. Or jump in the pool. Choose your adventure."
She didn't wait for an answer, just grabbed his hand and pulled. They were running toward the water, past the baseball players still replaying glory days, past everyone watching, and Marcus realized he was still holding her hand when they hit the surface.
The cap floated away toward the deep end, and he didn't go after it.
Underwater, everything was muffled and blue and simple. When he broke the surface, gasping, Jenna was laughing, and the baseball conversation felt miles away.
"Better?" she asked.
"Yeah," Marcus said, and realized he meant it. "Yeah."